A new approach to measuring multidirectional polarization


Mar 16, 2023

Model created by CSH scientist Samuel Martín-Gutiérrez and colleagues captures social division in multiparty democracies. The US could also benefit from it.  

Austria, India, Mexico, and Spain. As multiparty democracies, these countries present a more complex picture of what brings people together – or divides them. Using social media data, a group of researchers proposes a novel approach to measuring polarization in nations with multiple political parties.

 

Complexity Science Hub scientist Samuel Martín-Gutiérrez and his colleagues developed a model that infers opinions from social networks, and measures the left-right political division, as well as other more nuanced sources of tension. They analyzed Twitter data from the Spanish elections of 2015 and 2019.

 

“It’s important to understand polarization in our society, and our findings shed new light on how political beliefs are shaped,” says Martín-Gutiérrez. “Our approach can lead to useful insights when applied to real-world debates happening on social media.”

 

The findings of the study were recently published online in the journal Chaos, Solitons & Fractals.

 

The approach could be used in a variety of situations to identify the main points of disagreement. It could also be used in countries with two-party systems, such as the US. The primaries, a key part of the American voting system, are an excellent example, points out Martín-Gutiérrez. “There are several candidates in the presidential state primaries. Our model could be helpful in tracking and understanding how party members’ opinions are distributed” says the CSH researcher.

Neutral and unbiased

A key characteristic of the model, according to Martín-Gutiérrez, is its neutrality and unbiasedness. “We assumed we didn’t know anything about the [main Spanish] political parties in the study. And our findings demonstrate that a rigid classification of parties into pre-defined dimensions may not paint the most complete and accurate picture.”

 

Using Twitter data from two elections, Martín-Gutiérrez and his colleagues from the Universidad Politécnica de Madrid tested the proposed approach in practice. First, they explored the Spanish general elections of December 2015. In a second moment, they dissected the Spanish general elections of April 2019.

 

“In 2015, we had four opinion poles corresponding to the four main political parties: People’s Party (PP), Spanish Socialist Workers’ Party (PSOE), Podemos, and Citizens (Cs). In 2019, we have five opinion poles, with the addition of Vox,” explains Martín-Gutiérrez. 

 

As a first step, the team identified the opinion leaders, and their ideological positions, on Twitter. “The second step was to analyze the listeners, the interesting part of the network, and assign an opinion to a user according to the average opinion of the people they retweet”, says Martín-Gutiérrez.

 

Since the social spectrum is more complex and colorful than black and white, the researchers determined the same distance between every pair of poles to avoid bias. “In some contexts, it may seem more appropriate to place certain poles close together. For example, in an election certain political parties may be more ideologically aligned with each other than with the rest. However, parties that share ideology also compete for the same electoral base, often leading to even greater antagonism between them,” explain the authors of the study.

New knowledge

According to them, the opinion patterns of both analyses were consistent with the underlying Spanish social reality and could be interpreted taking into account their context. “There is a clear picture of the Spanish political spectrum, and we can see, for instance, where the opinion distribution is most stretched or where the average opinion is located,” says Martín-Gutiérrez.

 

“Our findings seem to be in line with what we intuitively know about Spanish politics. From this we can start building new knowledge, for instance, about citizens’ perceptions of politics and their behavior.”

 

In the visualization created by Liuhuaying Yang, CSH visualization expert, you can explore the opinion distribution of the 2015 Spanish elections: https://vis.csh.ac.at/multipolar-viz/3d/ 

(c) CSH
Opinion distribution of the 2015 Spanish elections: a cloud of users’ opinions with its center of mass marked with a red square and the principal components as arrows with lengths proportional to their explained variances

The proposed method could also assist policymakers in dealing with polarization and healing social rifts. “It could help policymakers devise de-escalation interventions by addressing the issues that cause the strongest tensions,” argue the authors of the study. 

 

Furthermore, it could be used to combat online misinformation spread by bots and trolls. The model could be used to evaluate the influence automated bots have on social media as compared to real human accounts.

 

The study “Multipolar social systems: Measuring polarization beyond dichotomous contexts” is available online at Chaos, Solitons & Fractals


Publication

M. Pangallo, A. Aleta, et al.

The unequal effects of the health-economy tradeoff during the COVID-19 pandemic

Nature Human Behaviour (2023) DOI: 10.1038/s41562-023-01747-x

Publication

P. Klimek, A. Aykac, S. Thurner

Forensic analysis of the Turkey 2023 presidential election reveals extreme vote swings in remote areas

PLoS ONE 18(11) (2023) e0293239

Press

Forscher sagt: „2024 wird das System in den USA möglicherweise zusammenbrechen“


Die Presse, Nov 14, 2023

Press

Why reports that Western civilisation will soon collapse are premature


New Scientist, Dec 5, 2023

Research News

Dec 6, 2023

A better way of measuring homophily

Spotlight

Nov 30, 2023

From Inequality to Instability

Publication

A. Nerpel, A. Käsbohrer, C. Walzer, A. Desvars-Larrive

Data on SARS-CoV-2 events in animals: Mind the gap!

One Health 17 (2023) 100653 DOI: 10.1016/j.onehlt.2023.100653

Unkategorisiert

Dec 6, 2023

From Leafy Woods to Data Forests

Press

Wissenschaft kritisiert fehlenden Datenzugang


ORF, Dec 4, 2023

Research News

Dec 6, 2023

A better way of measuring homophily

Unkategorisiert

Dec 6, 2023

From Leafy Woods to Data Forests

Spotlight

Nov 30, 2023

From Inequality to Instability

Research News

Nov 28, 2023

Proposals for an Efficient and Effective Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence in Europe

Research News

Nov 27, 2023

India's Rice Export Restrictions Echo in West Asia and Africa

Research News

Nov 23, 2023

Study Identifies Numerous Connections in Cybercrime Cases

Press

Nov 17, 2023

Invitation to media chat by Supply Chain Intelligence Institute Austria (ASCII)

Research News

Nov 15, 2023

Data Gap in SARS-CoV-2 Cases in Animals

News

Nov 14, 2023

FTX Collapse: New Method for Assessing the Solvency of Cryptocurrency Exchanges

People

Nov 10, 2023

Double Honors for CSH Researchers

News

Nov 13, 2023

New scientific methods for analyzing criminal careers

Press

Why reports that Western civilisation will soon collapse are premature


New Scientist, Dec 5, 2023

Press

Best ideas books of 2023


The Guardian, Dec 5, 2023

Press

Wissenschaft kritisiert fehlenden Datenzugang


ORF, Dec 4, 2023

Press

Forscher sagt: „2024 wird das System in den USA möglicherweise zusammenbrechen“


Die Presse, Nov 14, 2023

Press

Klima und Geschichte


Die Presse, Nov 4, 2023

Press

Daten mit Gewicht: Analysen von Lieferketten zeigen auch Steuerlücken


Die Presse, Oct 20, 2023

Press

Krypto-Forscher über DeFi: “Würde von De-facto-Centralized-Finance sprechen”


brutkasten, Oct 27, 2023

Press

Scientists say Western sanctions against China ‘toothless’ without better supply chain data


South China Morning Post, Oct 20, 2023

Press

Climate change has toppled some civilizations but not others. Why?


Grist, Oct 16, 2023

Press

Chinas E-Autos kommen, und Europa darf nicht naiv sein


Der Standard, Oct 9, 2023

Publication

P. Klimek, A. Aykac, S. Thurner

Forensic analysis of the Turkey 2023 presidential election reveals extreme vote swings in remote areas

PLoS ONE 18(11) (2023) e0293239

Publication

M. Pangallo, A. Aleta, et al.

The unequal effects of the health-economy tradeoff during the COVID-19 pandemic

Nature Human Behaviour (2023) DOI: 10.1038/s41562-023-01747-x

Publication

A. Nerpel, A. Käsbohrer, C. Walzer, A. Desvars-Larrive

Data on SARS-CoV-2 events in animals: Mind the gap!

One Health 17 (2023) 100653 DOI: 10.1016/j.onehlt.2023.100653

Publication

G. Heiler, T. Pham, J. Korbel, J. Wachs, S. Thurner

A large-scale empirical investigation of specialization in criminal career

Scientific Reports 13 (2023) 17160

Publication

A. Pichler, C. Diem, et al.

Building an alliance to map global supply networks: New firm-level data can inform policy-making

Science 382(6668) (2023) 270-272.

Publication

R. Prieto-Curiel, G. M. Capedelli, A. Hope

Reducing cartel recruitment is the only way to lower violence in Mexico

Science 381(6664) (2023) 1312-1316

Publication

B. Méro, A. Borsos, et al.

A High-Resolution, Data-Driven Agent-Based Model of the Housing Market

Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control (2023) 104738

Publication

S. Juhász, G. Pintér, et al.

Amenity complexity and urban locations of socio-economic mixing

EPJ Data Science 12 (2023) 34

Publication

R. Hanel, S. Thurner

Equivalence of information production and generalised entropies in complex processes

PLOS ONE 18(9) (2023) e0290695

Publication

K. Frenken, F. Neffke, A. van Dam

Capabilities, institutions and regional economic development: a proposed synthesis

Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society (2023) rsad021

Publication

G. Orlandi, D. Hoyer, et al.

Structural-demographic analysis of the Qing Dynasty (1644–1912) collapse in China

PLoS ONE 18(8) (2023) e0289748

Publication

N. Kushwaha, E.D. Lee

Discovering the mesoscale for chains of conflict

PNAS Nexus 2(7) (2023) pgad228