Bad times for despots: Scientists can detect electoral fraud - CSH Vienna

Bad times for despots: Scientists can detect electoral fraud


Jun 30, 2017

Complexity research reveils voting irregularities

 

Free elections are the cornerstone of any democracy. Up until now, only through great effort could electoral fraud and manipulation be proved.

 

Complexity researcher Peter Klimek, Medical University of Vienna and Complexity Science Hub Vienna, and colleagues from the Carlos III University of Madrid are now presenting a statistical procedure that makes it possible to detect signs of manipulation through publicly accessible electoral data. The work is published in the journal Science Advances. Findings on irregularities during the constitutional referendum in Turkey in April 2017 can be found online as well. The more remote the election sites, the greater the irregularities.

 

Ten countries analyzed

 

With a newly developed statistical method, Klimek and colleagues analyzed the official election results of 21 elections in ten countries, including elections in Russia from 2007 to 2011, Venezuela from 2006 to 2013, and Uganda in 2011. Data from Austria and other established democracies were also investigated.

 

This large number of observations led to certain statistical regularities in electoral data, such as the distribution of electoral participation and voting behavior across different parts of the country. “If these regularities do not occur in a data set or occur only in a strongly distorted form, it’s an indication that the voters were influenced.” While the elections in Austria, Finland, Canada, Spain, or France remained inconspicuous, the researchers found significant irregularities in some countries in the form of noticeable shifts of votes toward the government party. The smaller and more remote the voting stations, the stronger these displacements were. These distortions were even decisive in the presidential elections in Venezuela in 2013.

 

“The data clearly show that, in small and remote polling places, the influence of governmental groups on voters is a lot stronger than in anonymous urban areas, where the probability of being discovered by electoral observers is higher,” says Klimek. “Our method could usher in the end of hidden authoritarian practices in formal democratic institutions,” emphasizes Klimek. “In the future, electoral fraud could go from being purely suspicion and guessing to becoming a mathematically provable fact.”

 

In this context, the authors, together with Stefan Thurner of the Complexity Science Hub Vienna, IIASA, MedUni Vienna, and Santa Fe Institute, investigated the Turkish constitutional referendum from April 16, 2017. Immediately after the election, official observers criticized the possibility of allowing unauthenticated ballot papers to be allowed in electoral identification and access authorization at the polling stations or the prohibition of opening and counting ballots. As the researchers’ data analysis shows, these practices are indeed reflected in the same irregularities observed in Russia, Venezuela, or Uganda. Compared to these countries, the effects were weaker, but the narrow outcome of the referendum made them more selective. “We identified irregularities in about 6% of the election stations whose influence was just big enough to tilt the majority situation in favor of a ‘yes’ to constitutional change,” Klimek said.

 

 

Links:
Testing for voter rigging in small polling stations
Election forensic analysis of the Turkish Constitutional Referendum 2017


Press

Komplexitätsforscher Thurner warnt vor “Multikollaps”


ORF 2 | Aktuell nach Eins, Sep 30, 2020

Press

Forscher: Theorie erklärt Entwicklung der politischen Radikalisierung


Der Standard, Sep 29, 2020

Press

Mit Datenvielfalt die Krise bewältigen [print]


Tiroler Tageszeitung, Sep 28, 2020

Press

„Nicht nötig, Maßnahmen verpflichtend zu machen“


Krone.at, Sep 28, 2020

Publication

S. Thurner

Die Zerbrechlichkeit der Welt

(2020) edition a

News

Sep 25, 2020

Corona Traffic Light New shows details for EU regions

Publication

C. Deischinger, E. Dervic, M. Leutner, L. Kosi-Trebotic, P. Klimek, A. Kautzky-Willer

Diabetes mellitus is associated with a higher risk for major depressive disorder in women than in men

BMJ Open Diab Res Care 8 (2020) e001430

Publication

H. Krichene, H. Inoue, T. Isogai, A. Chakraborty

A model for indirect losses of negatives shocks in production and finance

PLoS ONE 15(9) (2020) e0239293

News

Sep 21, 2020

Austrian “Scientists of the Year”: More funding for blue sky research!

Publication

Ž. Tomovski, J. Dubbeldam, J. Korbel

Applications of Hilfer-Prabhakar operator to option pricing financial model

Fractional Calculus and Applied Analysis, Band 23, Heft 4 (2020)

News

Sep 4, 2020

Blog | Marcia Ferreira: “Measuring researcher mobility across institutions”

News

Aug 27, 2020

CCCSL: published in prominent company

Press

Komplexitätsforscher Thurner warnt vor “Multikollaps”


ORF 2 | Aktuell nach Eins, Sep 30, 2020

Press

Forscher: Theorie erklärt Entwicklung der politischen Radikalisierung


Der Standard, Sep 29, 2020

Press

Mit Datenvielfalt die Krise bewältigen [print]


Tiroler Tageszeitung, Sep 28, 2020

Press

„Nicht nötig, Maßnahmen verpflichtend zu machen“


Krone.at, Sep 28, 2020

Publication

S. Thurner

Die Zerbrechlichkeit der Welt

(2020) edition a

News

Sep 25, 2020

Corona Traffic Light New shows details for EU regions

Publication

C. Deischinger, E. Dervic, M. Leutner, L. Kosi-Trebotic, P. Klimek, A. Kautzky-Willer

Diabetes mellitus is associated with a higher risk for major depressive disorder in women than in men

BMJ Open Diab Res Care 8 (2020) e001430

Publication

H. Krichene, H. Inoue, T. Isogai, A. Chakraborty

A model for indirect losses of negatives shocks in production and finance

PLoS ONE 15(9) (2020) e0239293

News

Sep 21, 2020

Austrian “Scientists of the Year”: More funding for blue sky research!

Publication

Ž. Tomovski, J. Dubbeldam, J. Korbel

Applications of Hilfer-Prabhakar operator to option pricing financial model

Fractional Calculus and Applied Analysis, Band 23, Heft 4 (2020)

News

Sep 4, 2020

Blog | Marcia Ferreira: “Measuring researcher mobility across institutions”

News

Aug 27, 2020

CCCSL: published in prominent company

News

Sep 25, 2020

Corona Traffic Light New shows details for EU regions

News

Sep 21, 2020

Austrian “Scientists of the Year”: More funding for blue sky research!

News

Sep 4, 2020

Blog | Marcia Ferreira: “Measuring researcher mobility across institutions”

News

Aug 27, 2020

CCCSL: published in prominent company

News

Aug 24, 2020

Why COVID-19 infection curves behave so unexpectedly [EN, D]

News

Aug 3, 2020

Crazy ideas, brilliant minds, good times!

News

Jul 29, 2020

Corona | How far we move [June & July]

News

Jul 22, 2020

New CSH group leader predicted US unrest

News

Jul 17, 2020

When emotions go viral: analysis of the COVID-19 Infodemic

News

Jul 16, 2020

Blog | Marcia Ferreira: “Sentiment in news about COVID-19 research”

News

Jul 14, 2020

Corona: Which measures work? CSH has the ranking

News

Jun 30, 2020

Second wave ahead!

Press

Komplexitätsforscher Thurner warnt vor “Multikollaps”


ORF 2 | Aktuell nach Eins, Sep 30, 2020

Press

Forscher: Theorie erklärt Entwicklung der politischen Radikalisierung


Der Standard, Sep 29, 2020

Press

Mit Datenvielfalt die Krise bewältigen [print]


Tiroler Tageszeitung, Sep 28, 2020

Press

„Nicht nötig, Maßnahmen verpflichtend zu machen“


Krone.at, Sep 28, 2020

Press

Wiener Forscher erklären mit Modell politische Radikalisierung


APA Science, Sep 29, 2020

Press

Die Berechnung der Zukunft [print]


Kronen Zeitung, Sep 26, 2020

Press

Jetzt wird’s ernst [print]


pka Journal, Sep 25, 2020

Press

Mit Big Data die Welt retten – das neue Buch von Komplexitätsforscher Stefan Thurner: „Die Zerbrechlichkeit der Welt“


Energie Blog, Sep 26, 2020

Press

“Wir brauchen nur ein bisschen mehr Disziplin”


News, Sep 26, 2020

Press

Forscher erweitern ihr Ampelsystem


orf.at, Sep 25, 2020

Press

Neue Karte zeigt europaweit regionale Corona-Ampelfarben an


Der Standard, Sep 25, 2020

Press

Medien als zweite Haut [print]


NÖN, Sep 23, 2020

Publication

S. Thurner

Die Zerbrechlichkeit der Welt

(2020) edition a

Publication

C. Deischinger, E. Dervic, M. Leutner, L. Kosi-Trebotic, P. Klimek, A. Kautzky-Willer

Diabetes mellitus is associated with a higher risk for major depressive disorder in women than in men

BMJ Open Diab Res Care 8 (2020) e001430

Publication

H. Krichene, H. Inoue, T. Isogai, A. Chakraborty

A model for indirect losses of negatives shocks in production and finance

PLoS ONE 15(9) (2020) e0239293

Publication

Ž. Tomovski, J. Dubbeldam, J. Korbel

Applications of Hilfer-Prabhakar operator to option pricing financial model

Fractional Calculus and Applied Analysis, Band 23, Heft 4 (2020)

Publication

R. M. del Rio-Chanona, P. Mealy, A. Pichler, F. Lafond, J. D. Farmer

Supply and demand shocks in the COVID-19 pandemic: an industry and occupation perspective

Oxford Review of Economic Policy (2020) graa033

Publication

J. Kertész, J. Wachs

Complexity science approach to economic crime

Nature Reviews Physics (2020)

Publication

A. Chakraborty, H. Inoue, Y. Fujiwara

Economic complexity of prefectures in Japan

PLoS ONE 15(8) (2020) e0238017

Publication

A. Desvars-Larrive, E. Dervic, N. Haug, et al.

A structured open dataset of government interventions in response to COVID-19

Scientific Data Vol 7 (2020) Art no. 285

Publication

S. Thurner, P. Klimek, R. Hanel

A network-based explanation of why most COVID-19 infection curves are linear

PNAS Aug 24 (2020)

Publication

M. Kugler, S. Thurner

Complex Systems and Their Analysis [D, EN]

in: H. Androsch, W. Knoll, A. Plimon (Eds.), Discussing Technology—Complexity, Vienna (2020) Holzhausen (German / English)

Publication

J. Lasser

Creating an executable paper is a journey through Open Science

Communications Physics 3 (2020) 143

Publication

P. Turchin, A. Korotayev

The 2010 structural-demographic forecast for the 2010–2020 decade: A retrospective assessment

PLoS ONE 15 (8) (2020) e0237458