Blog | Andrew Ringsmuth: “How to deal with urgent global challenges”


May 12, 2021

Andrew Ringsmuth:

 

“Change the climate of empathy to tackle urgent global challenges”

 

Resources that can be openly accessed and depleted through over-exploitation are called ‘common-pool’ resources (CPRs). When a CPR is small, like a pasture or local fishery, resource harvesters can usually see how their behavior is affecting the resource level and restrain their harvesting accordingly to conserve the resource. However, when a CPR is very large, like the atmosphere or global biodiversity, it may be impossible for individuals to see how it is responding to their behavior. By the time society awakens to the need for conservation, it may be almost too late to organize successful collective action through behavioral change. Time is of the essence.

 

How to speed up behavior change

 

In our paper “Dynamics of collective action to conserve a large common-pool resource“, recently published in Scientific Reports with Astrid de Wijn and students, David Andersson and Sigrid Bratsberg of the Norwegian University of Science and Technology, we used an agent-based model to study the spread of behavioral change through a social network when an initially small number of people realize that society-wide conservation action is needed as soon as possible. We also tested the potential of different interventions to speed up this process.

 

We were able to show that the social dynamics unfold in two distinct stages.

 

In the first stage, society rapidly polarizes into clusters of people who cooperate with the needed behavioral changes, and those who deny them. These clusters act as self-reinforcing echo chambers, tending to maintain social polarization.

 

Struggle between echo chambers

 

The second, slower dynamical stage is a slow struggle between the clusters. Here, meaningful changes happen only at the clusters’ ‘edges’, where cooperators and deniers interact directly, trying to convert one another. Although the process is gradual, one side eventually wins as the opposing clusters dissolve inwards from their edges and society converges to a consensus.

 

These results indicate that the speed at which large-scale social change happens is limited by the speed with which echo chambers can be dissolved.

 

We found that this speed depends most strongly on the level of connectivity between agents, and on the influence of their broader sociopolitical environment. When agents are better connected, there are more opportunities for constructive interactions between disagreeing people, and even gentle nudges from the sociopolitical environment can give one side the advantage in these interactions, thus speeding up the convergence to consensus. Moreover, under some conditions there are tipping points at which even small changes in parameters like the strength of the nudge from the sociopolitical environment can determine whether the system converges to full denial or full cooperation.

 

Crucial rule of social media

 

Our modeling results suggest that media, and in particular, large-scale social media networks play a crucial role in determining our collective ability to reach consensus on urgent global challenges. These networks’ algorithms have learned to keep users engaged by exploiting their basic tribal instincts, either reinforcing a sense of belonging with already-agreeable content or stoking outrage with content that is seen to represent an objectionable outside group. The result is ideological echo chambers at an unprecedented scale and oversimplified, emotionally charged public discourse that makes it difficult to have the kind of communications needed: constructive engagement between disagreeing groups about urgent realities.

 

Social media can also have positive impact

 

On the bright side, however, with their now-huge memberships, social media are in a position to have a huge positive effect if they can find ways to adjust their business models. If they can continue to engage users while also exposing them to content that challenges misinformed views on climate change, for example, and also encourage empathy and constructive interactions between disagreeing groups, they may be able to transform themselves into powerful catalysts for positive social change.

 

The core messages from our work are, first, that large-scale social change requires people to reach out across ideological lines and discuss, empathically and constructively, with people who initially disagree with them. Those can be difficult conversations to have because no one likes to have their worldview challenged and we all tend to ignore evidence that makes us uncomfortable. But our research suggests that these kinds of interactions are vitally important if we want to act at the speed now required to mitigate urgent, global challenges like climate change and biodiversity loss.

 

Our second core message is that we can improve our chances of successful collective action by combining helpful factors. Favourable social connectivity and a sociopolitical environment that encourages positive change are more powerful together than either is alone.

Andrew Ringsmuth’s contribution to this work was completed durhing his time as a PostDoc at the CSH Vienna and MedUni Vienna (Feb to Dec 2020). He is now a PostDoc at the Wegener Center for Climate and Global Change at the University of Graz. He remains a member of the CSH Associate Faculty, so we will be staying in close contact.


Press

Das sind die Gründe, warum die Infektionszahlen jetzt sinken


Kurier, Sep 22, 2021

Press

Wien verschärft CoV-Maßnahmen ab Oktober


ORF 2 | ZIB 1, Sep 21, 2021

Press

Schärfere Regeln für Ungeimpfte in Wien


ATV | aktuell, Sep 21, 2021

Press

Trotz stagnierender Infektionen keine Entspannung


Der Standard, Sep 21, 2021

News

Sep 15, 2021

Impressions from this year's Hub Retreat

Publication

V. Machàcek, M. Srholec, M. R. Ferreira, et al.

Researchers’ institutional mobility: bibliometric evidence on academic inbreeding and internationalization

Science and Public Policy (2021) scab064

Publication

M. Hâncean, J. Lerner, M. Perc, M. Ghita, D. Bunaciu, A. Stoica, B. Mihaila

The role of age in the spreading of COVID-19 across a social network in Bucharest

Journal of Complex Networks 9 (4) (2021) cnab026

Publication

J. Einsiedler, et al.

Transferable Models to Understand the Impact of Lockdown Measures on Local Air Quality

in: Proceedings of the 3rd International Workshop on Urban Computing (UrbCom) (2021)

News

Sep 6, 2021

CSH in Albpach | The Great Green Transformation | Panel Discussion

News

Sep 1, 2021

Fariba Karimi nominated for Hedy Lamarr Award

Publication

V. Chuqiao Yang, M. Galesic, H. McGuinness, A. Harutyunyan

Dynamical system model predicts when social learners impair collective performance

PNAS 118 (35) (2021) e2106292118

News

Aug 2, 2021

The future of COVID-19 in Europe

Press

Das sind die Gründe, warum die Infektionszahlen jetzt sinken


Kurier, Sep 22, 2021

Press

Wien verschärft CoV-Maßnahmen ab Oktober


ORF 2 | ZIB 1, Sep 21, 2021

Press

Schärfere Regeln für Ungeimpfte in Wien


ATV | aktuell, Sep 21, 2021

Press

Trotz stagnierender Infektionen keine Entspannung


Der Standard, Sep 21, 2021

News

Sep 15, 2021

Impressions from this year's Hub Retreat

Publication

V. Machàcek, M. Srholec, M. R. Ferreira, et al.

Researchers’ institutional mobility: bibliometric evidence on academic inbreeding and internationalization

Science and Public Policy (2021) scab064

Publication

M. Hâncean, J. Lerner, M. Perc, M. Ghita, D. Bunaciu, A. Stoica, B. Mihaila

The role of age in the spreading of COVID-19 across a social network in Bucharest

Journal of Complex Networks 9 (4) (2021) cnab026

Publication

J. Einsiedler, et al.

Transferable Models to Understand the Impact of Lockdown Measures on Local Air Quality

in: Proceedings of the 3rd International Workshop on Urban Computing (UrbCom) (2021)

News

Sep 6, 2021

CSH in Albpach | The Great Green Transformation | Panel Discussion

News

Sep 1, 2021

Fariba Karimi nominated for Hedy Lamarr Award

Publication

V. Chuqiao Yang, M. Galesic, H. McGuinness, A. Harutyunyan

Dynamical system model predicts when social learners impair collective performance

PNAS 118 (35) (2021) e2106292118

News

Aug 2, 2021

The future of COVID-19 in Europe

News

Sep 15, 2021

Impressions from this year's Hub Retreat

News

Sep 6, 2021

CSH in Albpach | The Great Green Transformation | Panel Discussion

News

Sep 1, 2021

Fariba Karimi nominated for Hedy Lamarr Award

News

Aug 2, 2021

The future of COVID-19 in Europe

News

Jul 29, 2021

CSH and Austrian Railways OeBB launch joint project

News

Jul 28, 2021

Disease network analysis shows: healthy overweight is possible

News

Jul 22, 2021

New CSH team leader Frank Neffke & the "science of cities"

News

Jul 10, 2021

Peter Klimek about delta variant: "We must remain vigilant, also with kids"

News

Jul 7, 2021

Blog | Jenny Reddish: "Introduction to the new Crisis Databank at the Hub"

News

Jun 30, 2021

We proudly present: 5 years CSH | The Report

News

Jun 22, 2021

Digital Humanism: CSH successful with three projects

News

Jun 17, 2021

TU Wien–CSH Vienna COVID-19 project | Final Report

Press

Das sind die Gründe, warum die Infektionszahlen jetzt sinken


Kurier, Sep 22, 2021

Press

Wien verschärft CoV-Maßnahmen ab Oktober


ORF 2 | ZIB 1, Sep 21, 2021

Press

Schärfere Regeln für Ungeimpfte in Wien


ATV | aktuell, Sep 21, 2021

Press

Trotz stagnierender Infektionen keine Entspannung


Der Standard, Sep 21, 2021

Press

Stabilisierung nur eine kleine „Verschnaufpause“


Kronen Zeitung, Sep 21, 2021

Press

Experte rechnet mit Homeoffice-Pflicht für Ungeimpfte


Heute, Sep 19, 2021

Press

Peter Klimek: „Das Einzige, womit ich es erklären kann, ist die Oberösterreich-Wahl“


Die Presse, Sep 18, 2021

Press

Impfquote und Ansteckungsrate


Ö1 | Nachtjournal, Sep 17, 2021

Press

Ab wann die Ansteckungswelle gebrochen wird


ORF Science, Sep 17, 2021

Press

Gekipptes Fenster [Print]


Kronen Zeitung, Sep 17, 2021

Press

Ab wann die Ansteckungswelle gebrochen wird


Ö1 | Mittagsjournal, Sep 17, 2021

Press

Una red global de científicos medirá qué éxito tuvieron las medidas sanitarias para frenar la pandemia [Spanish]


Infobae, Sep 16, 2021

Publication

V. Machàcek, M. Srholec, M. R. Ferreira, et al.

Researchers’ institutional mobility: bibliometric evidence on academic inbreeding and internationalization

Science and Public Policy (2021) scab064

Publication

M. Hâncean, J. Lerner, M. Perc, M. Ghita, D. Bunaciu, A. Stoica, B. Mihaila

The role of age in the spreading of COVID-19 across a social network in Bucharest

Journal of Complex Networks 9 (4) (2021) cnab026

Publication

J. Einsiedler, et al.

Transferable Models to Understand the Impact of Lockdown Measures on Local Air Quality

in: Proceedings of the 3rd International Workshop on Urban Computing (UrbCom) (2021)

Publication

V. Chuqiao Yang, M. Galesic, H. McGuinness, A. Harutyunyan

Dynamical system model predicts when social learners impair collective performance

PNAS 118 (35) (2021) e2106292118

Publication

M. Hakkar,et al.

Enhancing rare earth element transfer from phosphate rock to phosphoric acid using an inexpensive fly ash additive

Minerals Engineering 172 (2021) 107166

Publication

Y. Zhang, et al.

Unified treatment of synchronization patterns in generalized networks with higher-order, multilayer, and temporal interactions

Communications Physics 4 (2021) 195

Publication

T. M. Pham, A. C. Alexander, J. Korbel, R. Hanel, S. Thurner

Balance and fragmentation in societies with homophily and social balance

Scientific Reports 11 (2021) 17188

Publication

S. U. Wetzels, et al.

Wolves, dogs and humans in regular contact can mutually impact each other’s skin microbiota

Scientific Reports 11 (2021) 17106

Publication

D. Wolpert, D. Kinney

Noisy Deductive Reasoning: How Humans Construct Math, and How Math Constructs Universes

in: A. Aguirre et al. (eds), Undecidability, Uncomputability and Unpredictability, Springer Cham 2021, 147-167

Publication

M. Serra-Peralta, J. Serrà, Á. Corral

Heaps’ law and vocabulary richness in the history of classical music harmony

EPJ Data Science 10 (2021) 40

Publication

A. Presbitero, V. Melnikov, V. Krzhizkhanovskaya, P. M. A. Sloot

A unifying model to estimate the effect of heat stress in the human innate immunity during physical activities

Scientific Reports 11 (2021) 16688

Publication

A.S. Sunahara, M. Perc, H.V. Ribeiro

Association between productivity and journal impact across disciplines and career age

Physical Review Research 3 (2021) 033158