Complex societies gave birth to big gods


Mar 20, 2019

Complex societies gave birth to big gods—not the other way around

 

Big data analyses suggest that moralizing gods are rather the product than the drivers of social complexity.

 

An international research team, including a member of the Complexity Science Hub Vienna, investigated the role of “big gods” in the rise of complex large-scale societies. Big gods are defined as moralizing deities who punish ethical transgressions. Contrary to prevailing theories, the team found that beliefs in big gods are a consequence, not a cause, of the evolution of complex societies. The results are published in the current issue of the journal Nature.

 

For their statistical analyses the researchers used the Seshat: Global History Databank, the most comprehensive, and constantly growing collection of historical and prehistorical data. Currently Seshat contains about 300,000 records on social complexity, religion, and other characteristics of 500 past societies, spanning 10,000 years of human history.

 

“It has been a debate for centuries why humans, unlike other animals, cooperate in large groups of genetically unrelated individuals,” says Seshat director and co-author Peter Turchin from the University of Connecticut and the Complexity Science Hub Vienna. Factors such as agriculture, warfare, or religion have been proposed as main driving forces.

 

One prominent theory, the big or moralizing gods hypothesis, assumes that religious beliefs were key. According to this theory people are more likely to cooperate fairly if they believe in gods who will punish them if they don’t. “To our surprise, our data strongly contradict this hypothesis,” says lead author Harvey Whitehouse. “In almost every world region for which we have data, moralizing gods tended to follow, not precede, increases in social complexity.” Even more so, standardized rituals tended on average to appear hundreds of years before gods who cared about human morality.

 

Such rituals create a collective identity and feelings of belonging that act as social glue, making people to behave more cooperatively. “Our results suggest that collective identities are more important to facilitate cooperation in societies than religious beliefs,” says Harvey Whitehouse.

 

 

Big data: a new approach to social theories

 

Until recently it has been impossible to distinguish between cause and effect in social theories and history, as standardized quantitative data from throughout world history were missing. To address this problem, data and social scientist Peter Turchin, together with Harvey Whitehouse and Pieter François from the University of Oxford, founded Seshat in 2011. The multidisciplinary project integrates the expertise of historians, archaeologists, anthropologists, social scientists as well as data scientists into a state-of-the-art, open-access database. Dozens of experts throughout the world helped to assemble detailed data on social complexity and religious beliefs and practices from hundreds of independent political units (“polities”), beginning with Neolithic Anatolians (today Turkey) in 9600 BCE.

 

CSH Press Release

 

Find here a more elaborate piece about the study by it’s authors from “The Conversation”.

The circles are coloured by type of moralizing gods.
Locations of the 30 sampled regions on the world map, labelled according to precolonial evidence of moralizing gods.Source: "Seshat: Global History Databank" | Nature

The complexity of a society can be estimated by social characteristics such as population, territory, and sophistication of government institutions and information systems. Religious data include the presence of beliefs in supernatural enforcement of reciprocity, fairness, and loyalty, and the frequency and standardization of religious rituals.

 

Seshat allows researchers to analyze hundreds of variables relating to social complexity, religion, warfare, agriculture and other features of human culture and society that vary over time and space,” explains Pieter François. “Now that the database is ready for analysis, we are poised to test a long list of theories about human history.” This includes competing theories of how and why humans evolved to cooperate in large-scale societies of millions and more people.

 

“Seshat is an unprecedented collaboration between anthropologists, historians, archaeologists, mathematicians, computer scientists, and evolutionary scientists”, says Patrick Savage, corresponding author of the article. “It shows how big data can revolutionize the study of human history.”

 

 

###

 

Harvey Whitehouse, Pieter François, Patrick E. Savage, […] Peter Turchin. (2019) “Complex societies precede moralizing gods throughout world history”, Nature http://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-019-1043-4

 

The published Seshat data are available at http://seshatdatabank.info/data

 


News

Sep 30, 2022

Supply Chains: The next big thing at the Hub

Publication

J. Lasser, S. Taofeek Aroyehun, et al.

Social media sharing of low quality news sources by political elites

PNAS Nexus (2022) pgac186

Research News

Sep 20, 2022

Data is a crucial tool against Covid-19

Press

Pourquoi la tech séduit de nouveau les étudiants américains [French] [feat. Peter Turchin]


L'Expansion, Sep 12, 2022

Publication

T. Reisch, G. Heiler, C. Diem, P. Klimek, S. Thurner

Monitoring supply networks from mobile phone data for estimating the systemic risk of an economy

Scientific Reports 12 (13347) (2022)

Press

¿Qué han aprendido los científicos de los confinamientos de la COVID19? [Spanish] [feat. Peter Klimek]


Viento Sur, Sep 9, 2022

Publication

R. Prieto Curiel, A. Schumann, I. Heo, P. Heinrigs

Detecting cities with high intermediacy in the African urban network

Computers, Environment and Urban Systems 98 (2022) 101869

Event

CSH Talk by Daniel Martin Katz: "Measuring and managing legal complexity"


Sep 30, 2022 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Event

CSH Talk by Kenji Itao: "Explaining universality and diversity in social phenomena using evolutionary simulation"


Oct 05, 2022 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

News

Sep 21, 2022

CSH awarded OENB basic funding

Press

SARS-Ani | Infographic of the week [feat. Amélie Desvars-Larrive & CSH Vis]


Nature Briefings, Sep 21, 2022

Event

CSH Talk by Pedro Moreno-Sánchez: "Privacy-preserving blockchain applications with adaptor signatures"


Oct 07, 2022 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

News

Sep 30, 2022

Supply Chains: The next big thing at the Hub

Publication

J. Lasser, S. Taofeek Aroyehun, et al.

Social media sharing of low quality news sources by political elites

PNAS Nexus (2022) pgac186

Research News

Sep 20, 2022

Data is a crucial tool against Covid-19

Press

Pourquoi la tech séduit de nouveau les étudiants américains [French] [feat. Peter Turchin]


L'Expansion, Sep 12, 2022

Publication

T. Reisch, G. Heiler, C. Diem, P. Klimek, S. Thurner

Monitoring supply networks from mobile phone data for estimating the systemic risk of an economy

Scientific Reports 12 (13347) (2022)

Press

¿Qué han aprendido los científicos de los confinamientos de la COVID19? [Spanish] [feat. Peter Klimek]


Viento Sur, Sep 9, 2022

Publication

R. Prieto Curiel, A. Schumann, I. Heo, P. Heinrigs

Detecting cities with high intermediacy in the African urban network

Computers, Environment and Urban Systems 98 (2022) 101869

Event

CSH Talk by Daniel Martin Katz: "Measuring and managing legal complexity"


Sep 30, 2022 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Event

CSH Talk by Kenji Itao: "Explaining universality and diversity in social phenomena using evolutionary simulation"


Oct 05, 2022 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

News

Sep 21, 2022

CSH awarded OENB basic funding

Press

SARS-Ani | Infographic of the week [feat. Amélie Desvars-Larrive & CSH Vis]


Nature Briefings, Sep 21, 2022

Event

CSH Talk by Pedro Moreno-Sánchez: "Privacy-preserving blockchain applications with adaptor signatures"


Oct 07, 2022 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

News

Sep 30, 2022

Supply Chains: The next big thing at the Hub

News

Sep 21, 2022

CSH awarded OENB basic funding

Research News

Sep 20, 2022

Data is a crucial tool against Covid-19

People

Sep 16, 2022

Andrea Rapisarda wins the Ig Nobel Prize for Economics

Research News

Aug 8, 2022

Scientists create computer risk model to tackle supply chain disruption

Research News

Jul 28, 2022

A stress test for the (Austrian) healthcare system

Research News

Jul 26, 2022

Study unveils first global dataset for SARS-CoV-2 infections in animals

People

Jul 18, 2022

Complexity GAINS | Toward a multifaceted and integrative science

People

Jul 13, 2022

Two months with two COSY Journalists in Residence

Research News

Jun 24, 2022

Testing theories on What drove the Holocene transformation

Spotlight

Jun 23, 2022

Cooperation agreement with Bavaria to fight internet criminality

Research News

Jun 21, 2022

Want to improve the company’s performance? Get more women on the boardroom

Press

SARS-Ani | Infographic of the week [feat. Amélie Desvars-Larrive & CSH Vis]


Nature Briefings, Sep 21, 2022

Press

¿Qué han aprendido los científicos de los confinamientos de la COVID19? [Spanish] [feat. Peter Klimek]


Viento Sur, Sep 9, 2022

Press

Pourquoi la tech séduit de nouveau les étudiants américains [French] [feat. Peter Turchin]


L'Expansion, Sep 12, 2022

Press

What scientists have learnt from COVID lockdowns [feat. Peter Klimek]


Nature News, Sep 7, 2022

Press

Geography Lessons From the 9/11 Terrorist Network [feat. Rafael Prieto Curiel]


Lawfare Blog, Sep 5, 2022

Press

Estudo inédito de Oxford e UFPE aponta que não há evidência de fraude nas eleições de 2018 [Portuguese] [feat. R. Hanel, P. Klimek, S. Thurner]


BBC News | Brasil, Sep 16, 2022

Press

為何會有「報復性投票」?!損人不利己的惡意行為,可能是追求公平正義路上的必要之惡?[Opinion] [feat. Peter Turchin]


Vocus, Sep 2, 2022

Press

Student Loan Forgiveness: A Payoff for the Woke [Opinion] [feat. Peter Turchin]


The New York Sun, Sep 2, 2022

Press

Kreislaufwirtschaft jetzt!


respACT, Aug 31, 2022

Press

50 años de caos o estabilidad [Spanish] [feat. Peter Turchin]


Vanguardia, Sep 16, 2022

Press

Wie wenige Unternehmen die Liefernetzwerke ins Schwanken bringen [feat. Stefan Thurner]


Factory Net, Sep 1, 2022

Press

Experte: Europa sollte seine Lieferketten besser kennen [feat. Stefan Thurner]


APA Science, Aug 27, 2022

Publication

J. Lasser, S. Taofeek Aroyehun, et al.

Social media sharing of low quality news sources by political elites

PNAS Nexus (2022) pgac186

Publication

R. Prieto Curiel, A. Schumann, I. Heo, P. Heinrigs

Detecting cities with high intermediacy in the African urban network

Computers, Environment and Urban Systems 98 (2022) 101869

Publication

T. Reisch, G. Heiler, C. Diem, P. Klimek, S. Thurner

Monitoring supply networks from mobile phone data for estimating the systemic risk of an economy

Scientific Reports 12 (13347) (2022)

Publication

G. De Marzo, F. Pandolfelli, V.D.P. Servedio

Modeling innovation in the cryptocurrency ecosystem

Scientific Reports 12 (12942) (2022)

Publication

A. Nerpel, et al.

SARS-ANI: a global open access dataset of reported SARS-CoV-2 events in animals

Scientific Data 9 (438) (2022)

Publication

M. Kaleta, J. Lasser, E. Dervic, et al.

Stress-testing the resilience of the Austrian healthcare system using agent-based simulation

Nature Communications 13 (4259) (2022)

Publication

F. Amman, et al.

Viral variant-resolved wastewater surveillance of SARS-CoV-2 at national scale

Nature Biotechnology (2022)

Publication

J. V. Camp, A. Desvars-Larrive, N. Nowotny, C. Walzer

Monitoring urban zoonotic virus activity: Are city rats a promising surveillance tool for emerging viruses?

Viruses 14 (7) (2022) 1516

Publication

M. Pellert, H. Metzler, M. Matzenberger, D. Garcia

Validating daily social media macroscopes of emotions

Scientific Reports 12 (2022) 11236

Publication

P. Turchin, et al.

Disentangling the evolutionary drivers of social complexity in human history: A comprehensive test of hypotheses

Science Advances 8 (25) (2022)

Publication

R. Prieto Curiel, H. González Ramírez, S. Bishop

A ubiquitous collective tragedy in transport

Frontiers in Physics (2022)

Publication

M. Oliveira, F. Karimi, et al.

Group mixing drives inequality in face-to-face gatherings

Communications Physics 5 (127) (2022)

Event

CSH Talk by Daniel Martin Katz: "Measuring and managing legal complexity"


Sep 30, 2022 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Event

CSH Talk by Kenji Itao: "Explaining universality and diversity in social phenomena using evolutionary simulation"


Oct 05, 2022 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Event

CSH Talk by Pedro Moreno-Sánchez: "Privacy-preserving blockchain applications with adaptor signatures"


Oct 07, 2022 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Event

CSH Talk by Tommaso Rughi: "Climate change and labour-saving technologies"


Oct 14, 2022 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Event

CSH Workshop: "Evolution and geography of collective knowledge"


Oct 17, 2022Oct 19, 2022

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Event

CSH Workshop: "Collective Resilience"


Oct 19, 2022Oct 21, 2022

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Event

CSH Talk by Elisa Omodei: "Complexity and data-driven approaches to monitor the SDGs..."


Oct 28, 2022 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Event

CSH Talk by Philipp Koch: "The historical role of migrants in the geography of knowledge"


Nov 04, 2022 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Event

CSH Talk by Veronica Mierzejewski: "Scaling in biochemistry and how novel functions arise..."


Oct 25, 2022 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Event

CSH Webtalk by Beate Conrady: "Agent-based-spread-model for Salmonella Dublin Infections..."


Nov 23, 2022 | 15:0016:00