Which measures work best? The final results - CSH

Which measures work best? The final results


Nov 25, 2020

The whole world is keen to know what measures work best against the spread of COVID-19.

 

Here is the final ranking

 

With our preprint on non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) against COVID-19 we garnered a lot of attention this summer. On November 16, the peer-reviewed article was finally published in the prestigious journal “Nature Human Behaviour.”

 

The final publication analyses—with four different approaches—an even larger sample of interventions than the summer version. For the preprint, our collection of measures—the Complexity Science Hub COVID-19 Control Strategies List (CCCCSL)—contained 4,600 individual measures in 76 territories worldwide. The final version made use of 6,068 hierarchically coded interventions implemented in 79 territories, including more than twenty US States, European countries, and Asian regions like Japan and Hong Kong.

 

In addition, the researchers also validated their findings with two external datasets: the WHO-PHSM dataset https://www.who.int/emergencies/diseases/novel-coronavirus-2019/phsm and the huge CoronaNet project https://www.coronanet-project.org.

 

 

Overall conclusions have not changed much from the preprint.

 

The most effective non-pharmaceutical interventions against COVID-19 continue to be measures of social distancing. Specifically, the cancellation of small gatherings and the closure of educational institutions are at the top of the ranking, followed by border restrictions and the availability of protection gear such as face masks (remember: the collections of measures were collected in the first wave of the pandemic in spring).

Closing schools

 

However, says principal investigator Peter Klimek, “no measure can be viewed in isolation.” For example, if children cannot go to school, parents at least of younger children will have to stay at home too. Inevitably, this reduces potentially contagious contacts of the whole household.

 

“The scientific community still does not know exactly to what extent small children are a factor in spreading the virus,” says Peter. “Yet, what we clearly see in our analyzes is: If educational institutions are closed, the famous R(t)—the number of people a sick person infects on average—goes down by around 0.2.”

 

0.2? That does not sound like very much…

 

In fact, as Peter has been stressing unceasingly since the summer, it is never one individual measure that leads to success. It is always a bundle of measures, including such diverse interventions as an increase in healthcare and public health capacities, movement restrictions, travel warnings or a pro-active communication with the public.

 

This is good news, Peter says: “Although a hard lockdown is very effective, it has huge consequences for the society and therefore should be avoided if possible. How to avoid it? With a clever mix of ‘softer’ measures.” Whereby the correct timing is of utmost importance: The earlier measures are implemented, the more effective they are, Peter and his colleagues found.

 

 

Communication is highly effective

 

One of the important and well-working interventions is, maybe somewhat unexpected, a comprehensive and well-designed risk communication. “Information really is key,” says Peter. “Politicians and health authorities should reach out to the public with reliable information and recommendations as early as possible.”

 

As the pandemic continues, the threat of negative scenarios might wear off. In contrast, Peter points out, giving the public insights and reliable information could have long lasting positive effects in the fight against COVID-19, as well as or for possible future pandemics.

 

If and how well it works, will be part of a future study aiming to analyze the effectiveness of interventions during the second lockdown.


Press

Corona-Modellprojekte: Ist der Tübinger Weg eine Sackgasse?


Augsburger Allgemeine, Apr 7, 2021

Press

Lockdown in Ostösterreich verlängert


Ö2 | Niederösterreich | Journal, Apr 7, 2021

Press

Handel tobt: Lockdown “kann nicht richtiger Weg sein”


Heute, Apr 6, 2021

Press

Lässt sich die dritte Welle brechen?


Der Standard, Apr 6, 2021

News

Apr 1, 2021

CSH Winter Lecture Series: from the Alps to Zoom

Publication

J. Korbel, D. Wolpert

Stochastic thermodynamics and fluctuation theorems for non-linear systems

New Journal of Physics 23 (2021) 033049

News

Mar 17, 2021

The City Formula or: It’s all about geometry!

Publication

C. Molinero, S. Thurner

How the geometry of cities determines urban scaling laws

Journal of the Royal Society Interface 18 (176) (2021)

News

Mar 12, 2021

Videos out!!! Watch the Covid-19 Measures Tracker Conference

Publication

E. Vasilyaeva, et al.

Multilayer representation of collaboration networks with higher-order interactions

Scientific Reports 11 (2021) 5666

Publication

F. Schweitzer, G. Casiraghi, M. Tomasello, D. Garcia

Fragile, yet resilient: Adaptive decline in a collaboration network of firms

Frontiers in Applied Mathematics and Statistics 7 (2021) 634006

News

Mar 5, 2021

Hostile attitudes to migrants harden by short-term exposure

Press

Corona-Modellprojekte: Ist der Tübinger Weg eine Sackgasse?


Augsburger Allgemeine, Apr 7, 2021

Press

Lockdown in Ostösterreich verlängert


Ö2 | Niederösterreich | Journal, Apr 7, 2021

Press

Handel tobt: Lockdown “kann nicht richtiger Weg sein”


Heute, Apr 6, 2021

Press

Lässt sich die dritte Welle brechen?


Der Standard, Apr 6, 2021

News

Apr 1, 2021

CSH Winter Lecture Series: from the Alps to Zoom

Publication

J. Korbel, D. Wolpert

Stochastic thermodynamics and fluctuation theorems for non-linear systems

New Journal of Physics 23 (2021) 033049

News

Mar 17, 2021

The City Formula or: It’s all about geometry!

Publication

C. Molinero, S. Thurner

How the geometry of cities determines urban scaling laws

Journal of the Royal Society Interface 18 (176) (2021)

News

Mar 12, 2021

Videos out!!! Watch the Covid-19 Measures Tracker Conference

Publication

E. Vasilyaeva, et al.

Multilayer representation of collaboration networks with higher-order interactions

Scientific Reports 11 (2021) 5666

Publication

F. Schweitzer, G. Casiraghi, M. Tomasello, D. Garcia

Fragile, yet resilient: Adaptive decline in a collaboration network of firms

Frontiers in Applied Mathematics and Statistics 7 (2021) 634006

News

Mar 5, 2021

Hostile attitudes to migrants harden by short-term exposure

News

Apr 1, 2021

CSH Winter Lecture Series: from the Alps to Zoom

News

Mar 17, 2021

The City Formula or: It’s all about geometry!

News

Mar 12, 2021

Videos out!!! Watch the Covid-19 Measures Tracker Conference

News

Mar 5, 2021

Hostile attitudes to migrants harden by short-term exposure

News

Feb 18, 2021

(Re)Shaping cities to combat inequality

News

Jan 26, 2021

Different Lockdowns, different mobility in Austria

News

Jan 18, 2021

Stefan Thurner: “It needs digitization to fight a pandemic”

News

Jan 11, 2021

Central European University: the newest Hub member

News

Dec 19, 2020

Call for Pan-European Corona strategy

News

Dec 9, 2020

Corona and subway use in Vienna

News

Dec 3, 2020

Cryptofinance: our new research field!

News

Dec 1, 2020

What is a Complex System? A new book explains

Press

Corona-Modellprojekte: Ist der Tübinger Weg eine Sackgasse?


Augsburger Allgemeine, Apr 7, 2021

Press

Lockdown in Ostösterreich verlängert


Ö2 | Niederösterreich | Journal, Apr 7, 2021

Press

Handel tobt: Lockdown “kann nicht richtiger Weg sein”


Heute, Apr 6, 2021

Press

Lässt sich die dritte Welle brechen?


Der Standard, Apr 6, 2021

Press

Forscher zu Entwicklung Cov-Zahlen


ORF 2 | Wien heute, Apr 6, 2021

Press

Ostösterreich bleibt (länger) zu Hause


Wiener Zeitung, Apr 6, 2021

Press

Talk mit Christoph Varga


ORF 2 | Guten Morgen Österreich, Apr 6, 2021

Press

Systematisch erschöpft


Wiener Zeitung, Apr 5, 2021

Press

Drei Thesen, warum Tirol wie ein Corona-Dauer-Hotspot wirkt


Die Presse, Apr 3, 2021

Press

Covid-19: Testes rápidos em massa não são “carta branca para a liberdade” [Portuguese]


Publico, Apr 3, 2021

Press

Studie zeigt: „Osterruhe“ hilft uns aus der Krise


Kronen Zeitung, Apr 3, 2021

Press

Ampel-Kommission: Stufenplan für die Länder zur Lockdown-Vermeidung


OÖ Nachrichten, Apr 3, 2021

Publication

J. Korbel, D. Wolpert

Stochastic thermodynamics and fluctuation theorems for non-linear systems

New Journal of Physics 23 (2021) 033049

Publication

C. Molinero, S. Thurner

How the geometry of cities determines urban scaling laws

Journal of the Royal Society Interface 18 (176) (2021)

Publication

E. Vasilyaeva, et al.

Multilayer representation of collaboration networks with higher-order interactions

Scientific Reports 11 (2021) 5666

Publication

F. Schweitzer, G. Casiraghi, M. Tomasello, D. Garcia

Fragile, yet resilient: Adaptive decline in a collaboration network of firms

Frontiers in Applied Mathematics and Statistics 7 (2021) 634006

Publication

F. Parastesh, et al.

Chimeras

Physics Reports 898 (2021) 1–114

Publication

A. Pluchino, et al.

A novel methodology for epidemic risk assessment of COVID-19 outbreak

Scientific Reports 11 (2021) 5304

Publication

S. Thurner, P. Klimek, R. Hanel

Reply to Kuśmierz and Toyoizumi: A network-based explanation of why most COVID-19 infection curves are linear

PNAS 118 (10) (2021) e2100906118

Publication

E. Filtz, S. Kirrane, A. Polleres

The linked legal data landscape: linking legal data across different countries

Artificial Intelligence and Law (2021)

Publication

J. Korbel, S. Lindner, R. Hanel, S. Thurner

Thermodynamics of structure-forming systems

Nature Communications 12 (2021) 1127

Publication

G. Tóth, J. Wachs, et al.

Inequality is rising where social network segregation interacts with urban topology

Nature Communications 12 (2021) 1143

Publication

E. Ubaldi, R. Burioni, V. Loreto, F. Tria

Emergence and evolution of social networks through exploration of the adjacent possible space

Communication Physics 4 (2021) 28

Publication

M. Leutner, et al.

Major Depressive Disorder (MDD) and antidepressant medication are overrepresented in high-dose Statin treatment

Frontiers in Medicine 8 (2021) 608083