Which measures work best? The final results


Nov 25, 2020

The whole world is keen to know what measures work best against the spread of COVID-19.

 

Here is the final ranking

 

With our preprint on non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) against COVID-19 we garnered a lot of attention this summer. On November 16, the peer-reviewed article was finally published in the prestigious journal “Nature Human Behaviour.”

 

The final publication analyses—with four different approaches—an even larger sample of interventions than the summer version. For the preprint, our collection of measures—the Complexity Science Hub COVID-19 Control Strategies List (CCCCSL)—contained 4,600 individual measures in 76 territories worldwide. The final version made use of 6,068 hierarchically coded interventions implemented in 79 territories, including more than twenty US States, European countries, and Asian regions like Japan and Hong Kong.

 

In addition, the researchers also validated their findings with two external datasets: the WHO-PHSM dataset https://www.who.int/emergencies/diseases/novel-coronavirus-2019/phsm and the huge CoronaNet project https://www.coronanet-project.org.

 

 

Overall conclusions have not changed much from the preprint.

 

The most effective non-pharmaceutical interventions against COVID-19 continue to be measures of social distancing. Specifically, the cancellation of small gatherings and the closure of educational institutions are at the top of the ranking, followed by border restrictions and the availability of protection gear such as face masks (remember: the collections of measures were collected in the first wave of the pandemic in spring).

Closing schools

 

However, says principal investigator Peter Klimek, “no measure can be viewed in isolation.” For example, if children cannot go to school, parents at least of younger children will have to stay at home too. Inevitably, this reduces potentially contagious contacts of the whole household.

 

“The scientific community still does not know exactly to what extent small children are a factor in spreading the virus,” says Peter. “Yet, what we clearly see in our analyzes is: If educational institutions are closed, the famous R(t)—the number of people a sick person infects on average—goes down by around 0.2.”

 

0.2? That does not sound like very much…

 

In fact, as Peter has been stressing unceasingly since the summer, it is never one individual measure that leads to success. It is always a bundle of measures, including such diverse interventions as an increase in healthcare and public health capacities, movement restrictions, travel warnings or a pro-active communication with the public.

 

This is good news, Peter says: “Although a hard lockdown is very effective, it has huge consequences for the society and therefore should be avoided if possible. How to avoid it? With a clever mix of ‘softer’ measures.” Whereby the correct timing is of utmost importance: The earlier measures are implemented, the more effective they are, Peter and his colleagues found.

 

 

Communication is highly effective

 

One of the important and well-working interventions is, maybe somewhat unexpected, a comprehensive and well-designed risk communication. “Information really is key,” says Peter. “Politicians and health authorities should reach out to the public with reliable information and recommendations as early as possible.”

 

As the pandemic continues, the threat of negative scenarios might wear off. In contrast, Peter points out, giving the public insights and reliable information could have long lasting positive effects in the fight against COVID-19, as well as or for possible future pandemics.

 

If and how well it works, will be part of a future study aiming to analyze the effectiveness of interventions during the second lockdown.


News

Sep 21, 2023

Curbing the Violence by Mexican Cartels

Publication

R. Prieto-Curiel, G. M. Capedelli, A. Hope

Reducing cartel recruitment is the only way to lower violence in Mexico

Science 381(6664) (2023) 1312-1316

Press

Study reveals organized crime is the fifth-largest employer in Mexico


El Pais, Sep 22, 2023

News

Sep 18, 2023

Unlocking Urban Diversity: The Magnetism of Complex Amenities

Publication

S. Juhász, G. Pintér, et al.

Amenity complexity and urban locations of socio-economic mixing

EPJ Data Science 12 (2023) 34

Press

175.000 personas al servicio de los cárteles mexicanos, según estudio


CNN, Sep 22, 2023

Publication

B. Méro, A. Borsos, et al.

A High-Resolution, Data-Driven Agent-Based Model of the Housing Market

Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control (2023) 104738

News

Sep 18, 2023

Why do some environmental shocks lead to disaster while others don't?

Press

Es gibt auch gute Klima-Nachrichten


SZ, Sep 22, 2023

News

Sep 21, 2023

Curbing the Violence by Mexican Cartels

News

Sep 18, 2023

Unlocking Urban Diversity: The Magnetism of Complex Amenities

News

Sep 18, 2023

Why do some environmental shocks lead to disaster while others don't?

News

Aug 31, 2023

New study uncovers the Causes of the Qing Dynasty's Collapse

News

Aug 28, 2023

CSH hosts workshop on visualizing complexity science

Spotlight

Aug 22, 2023

Wallet 2.0: What Does the Future of Money Look Like?

Spotlight

Aug 14, 2023

Open Arms Grant: How conferences can ensure global participation

News

Aug 1, 2023

Scientists develop method to spot the spread of armed conflicts

News

Jul 27, 2023

A lot of exchanges and discussions at NetSci

News

Jul 20, 2023

Prenatal malnutrition increases diabetes incidence later in life

Spotlight

Jun 29, 2023

CSH Spin-Off Iknaio receives aws seed funding

Press

175.000 personas al servicio de los cárteles mexicanos, según estudio


CNN, Sep 22, 2023

Press

Study reveals organized crime is the fifth-largest employer in Mexico


El Pais, Sep 22, 2023

Press

Es gibt auch gute Klima-Nachrichten


SZ, Sep 22, 2023

Press

Kindesmissbrauch: Wie Kriminelle die Anonymität des Darknets nutzen


Kurier, Sep 7, 2023

Press

L'effondrement de la dernière dynastie chinoise des Qing, un avertissement pour le futur ?


GEO, Sep 6, 2023

Press

Warum Saudi-Arabiens ehrgeizige Stadt der Zukunft nicht optimal ist


Spektrum der Wissenschaft, Sep 6, 2023

Press

Qing Dynasty’s Collapse Driven By Three Things, And They Could Happen To Us


IFL Science, Sep 4, 2023

Press

Warum die Qing-Dynastie unterging


ORF, Sep 5, 2023

Press

There are thousands of cities in the world, and there’s a reason none is in the shape of a line


Fast Company, Aug 12, 2023

Publication

R. Prieto-Curiel, G. M. Capedelli, A. Hope

Reducing cartel recruitment is the only way to lower violence in Mexico

Science 381(6664) (2023) 1312-1316

Publication

B. Méro, A. Borsos, et al.

A High-Resolution, Data-Driven Agent-Based Model of the Housing Market

Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control (2023) 104738

Publication

S. Juhász, G. Pintér, et al.

Amenity complexity and urban locations of socio-economic mixing

EPJ Data Science 12 (2023) 34

Publication

R. Hanel, S. Thurner

Equivalence of information production and generalised entropies in complex processes

PLOS ONE 18(9) (2023) e0290695

Publication

K. Frenken, F. Neffke, A. van Dam

Capabilities, institutions and regional economic development: a proposed synthesis

Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society (2023) rsad021

Publication

G. Orlandi, D. Hoyer, et al.

Structural-demographic analysis of the Qing Dynasty (1644–1912) collapse in China

PLoS ONE 18(8) (2023) e0289748

Publication

N. Kushwaha, E.D. Lee

Discovering the mesoscale for chains of conflict

PNAS Nexus 2(7) (2023) pgad228

Publication

H. Metzler, D. Garcia

Social Drivers and Algorithmic Mechanisms on Digital Media

Perspectives on Psychological Science (2023)

Publication

M. Laber, P. Klimek, et al.

Shock propagation from the Russia–Ukraine conflict on international multilayer food production network determines global food availability

Nature Food (2023) doi: 10.1038/s43016-023-00771-4

Publication

M. Kaleta, et al.

Diabetes incidence in Austria: The role of famines on diabetes and related NCDs

Helyion, Volume 9, Issue 7, July 2023, e17570

Publication

D. R. Lo Sardo, S. Thurner, et al.

Systematic population-wide ecological analysis of regional variability in disease prevalence

Heliyon 9(4) (2023) e15377

Publication

R. Prieto-Curiel, J. E. Patino, B. Anderson

Scaling of the morphology of African cities

PNAS 120 (9) (2023) e2214254120