Lockdown as live experiment reveals men-women behavioral differences


Sep 28, 2021

New CSH study finds big behavioral gender differences during Corona lockdown

 

How do communication or movement patterns change in an acute crisis? Hub researchers see major trends in anonymized telecommunication data—and identify clear gender differences.

 

In a crisis, women make significantly longer phone calls and adhere more closely to governmental measures than men; men are less likely to have their mobility restricted and return to normal more quickly than women. CSH scientists found cliché-sounding behavioral patterns like these in data from the first Corona lockdown in spring 2020.

 

For their study—it just appeared in the journal Scientific ReportsTobias Reisch and Georg Heiler as first authors evaluated mobile phone data from 1.2 million Austrians—about 15 percent of the population—between February and June 2020. The otheer authors are CSH scientists Jan Hurt, Peter Klimek, Allan Hanbury, and Stefan Thurner

 

Men and women behave very differently

 

“The total shutdown of public life was like a population-wide live experiment,” Tobias points out. In spring 2020, the Hub was given access to anonymized telecommunication data from a major Austrian internet service provider. The scientists used the data to observe, with a slight time-lag, people’s mobility behavior.

 

“We were interested in the extent to which people supported the anti-Corona measures imposed by the government,” Tobias says. “When we analyzed the data by gender, we found surprisingly strong behavioral differences between men and women.” (Note: The gender categories are self-reported and are, for technical reasons, limited to female and male.)

 

Women make longer phone-calls, men go out more likely

 

People made much longer phone calls right after the lockdown was imposed. “Interestingly, they talked to fewer people than usual—but with these few, they spoke longer,” Tobias explains.

As the figure shows, phone calls involving women lasted significantly longer on average, with big differences depending on who was calling whom. After the first lockdown in Austria was imposed on March 16, women to women calls were up to 1,5 times longer than before the crisis (+140 percent), calls from men to women lasted nearly twice as long. Conversely, when women called men, they talked 80 percent longer, while the duration of calls between men rose only by 66 percent.

 

“Of course, we don’t know the content or purpose of these calls,” adds Georg, who was responsible for data processing. “Yet, literature from the social sciences provides evidence—mostly from small surveys, polls, or interviews—that women tend to choose more active strategies to cope with stress, such as talking with others. Our study would confirm that.”

 

The scientists also found that already existing differences in the mobility behavior of men and women were massively amplified by the lockdown, with women limiting their mobility significantly more and for longer than men.

 

The more detailed evaluation of telecom data gained from a large recreational area in Vienna and from a shopping mall shows that both regions were more likely to be frequented by men during the lockdown. Also, after the measures were lifted, men returned more quickly to their pre-pandemic mobility patterns.

 

A valuable support for social sciences

 

“This study shows once again that data—in this case telecommunication data—allows us to gain social insights quickly and at low costs, without violating the anonymity of individuals,” adds our President Stefan. “We see people’s behavior in the here and now without the need for large surveys of thousands of people.”

 

On the one hand, this offers quantitative support for research questions in psychology and the social sciences—including interesting new questions emerging from data evaluations. “On the other hand, we are providing concrete information for policymakers which can either be used for planning in an acute crisis, or flow into a more targeted health planning, or could even lead to considerations on how to achieve a more gender-equitable society,” Stefan concludes.

 

 

The study “Behavioral gender differences are reinforced during the COVID-19 crisis” was published in the journal Scientific Reports on Sept 28, 2021.


Press

Lockdown in Österreich bisher nur mit geringem Effekt


Der Tagesspiegel, Dec 2, 2021

News

Nov 30, 2021

Mobility Changes during the 4th Lockdown in Austria

News

Nov 30, 2021

Disentangling the CSH networks

Press

Covid-19 vaccine mandates are divisive, but they can work. Europe is starting to show how


CNN | World, Nov 30, 2021

Press

Alarmojnë ekspertët austriakë: Kosova mund të paguajë çmim të lartë me COVID’in [Albanian]


Gazeta Express, Nov 30, 2021

News

Nov 29, 2021

Santa Fe Institute & CSH invite to International Summer School in Vienna

News

Nov 26, 2021

Mobility changes in Austria in fall 2021

Press

Scapegoating the Private School Boy


Quillette, Nov 26, 2021

Publication

L. Alves, D. Rybski, H. Ribeiro

Commuting network effect on urban wealth scaling

Scientific Reports 11 (2021) 22918

Publication

F. Papst, K. Schodl, O. Saukh

Exploring Co-dependency of IoT Data Quality and Model Robustness in Precision Cattle Farming

in: Proceedings of the 19th ACM Conference on Embedded Networked Sensor Systems (SenSys) '21 (Nov 2021) 433–438

Publication

X. Bao, P. Ji, W. Lin, M. Perc, J. Kurths

The impact of COVID-19 on the worldwide air transportation network

Royal Society Open Science 8 (11) (2021) 210682

Publication

P. Dutta, et al.

Inferring temporal dynamics from cross-sectional data using Langevin dynamics

Royal Society Open Science (8) (2021) 211374

Press

Lockdown in Österreich bisher nur mit geringem Effekt


Der Tagesspiegel, Dec 2, 2021

News

Nov 30, 2021

Mobility Changes during the 4th Lockdown in Austria

News

Nov 30, 2021

Disentangling the CSH networks

Press

Covid-19 vaccine mandates are divisive, but they can work. Europe is starting to show how


CNN | World, Nov 30, 2021

Press

Alarmojnë ekspertët austriakë: Kosova mund të paguajë çmim të lartë me COVID’in [Albanian]


Gazeta Express, Nov 30, 2021

News

Nov 29, 2021

Santa Fe Institute & CSH invite to International Summer School in Vienna

News

Nov 26, 2021

Mobility changes in Austria in fall 2021

Press

Scapegoating the Private School Boy


Quillette, Nov 26, 2021

Publication

L. Alves, D. Rybski, H. Ribeiro

Commuting network effect on urban wealth scaling

Scientific Reports 11 (2021) 22918

Publication

F. Papst, K. Schodl, O. Saukh

Exploring Co-dependency of IoT Data Quality and Model Robustness in Precision Cattle Farming

in: Proceedings of the 19th ACM Conference on Embedded Networked Sensor Systems (SenSys) '21 (Nov 2021) 433–438

Publication

X. Bao, P. Ji, W. Lin, M. Perc, J. Kurths

The impact of COVID-19 on the worldwide air transportation network

Royal Society Open Science 8 (11) (2021) 210682

Publication

P. Dutta, et al.

Inferring temporal dynamics from cross-sectional data using Langevin dynamics

Royal Society Open Science (8) (2021) 211374

News

Nov 30, 2021

Mobility Changes during the 4th Lockdown in Austria

News

Nov 30, 2021

Disentangling the CSH networks

News

Nov 29, 2021

Santa Fe Institute & CSH invite to International Summer School in Vienna

News

Nov 26, 2021

Mobility changes in Austria in fall 2021

News

Nov 18, 2021

Apply to take part in the CSH Winter School 2022 on Green Transition in Tyrol

News

Nov 3, 2021

CSH data analyses show where dairy cows are (least) healthy

News

Oct 20, 2021

What drove the invention of military technologies?

News

Oct 20, 2021

How Bali could teach the world to manage its limited resources

News

Oct 14, 2021

Vito, Niklas & Vittorio implement Kouzan_Expo in Rome

News

Oct 12, 2021

Massive fraud in Duma elections 2021

News

Sep 28, 2021

Lockdown as live experiment reveals men-women behavioral differences

News

Sep 15, 2021

Impressions from this year's Hub Retreat

Press

Lockdown in Österreich bisher nur mit geringem Effekt


Der Tagesspiegel, Dec 2, 2021

Press

Covid-19 vaccine mandates are divisive, but they can work. Europe is starting to show how


CNN | World, Nov 30, 2021

Press

Alarmojnë ekspertët austriakë: Kosova mund të paguajë çmim të lartë me COVID’in [Albanian]


Gazeta Express, Nov 30, 2021

Press

Scapegoating the Private School Boy


Quillette, Nov 26, 2021

Press

Can history teach us anything about the future of war — and peace?


Taipei Times, Nov 23, 2021

Press

Meet the Media Guru Around Mobility: incontro con Vittorio Loreto [Italian]


Mente Locale, Nov 22, 2021

Press

“Parece que no hay otro remedio que el confinamiento, pero espero poder disfrutar de las Navidades” [Spanish]


El Pais, Nov 21, 2021

Press

AT: Mikrodaten-Center wird Beforschung von Statistikdaten erleichtern


DMZ - Die Mittelländische Zeitung, Nov 21, 2021

Press

Lockdown und Impfpflicht für alle


ORF 2 | ZIB 2, Nov 19, 2021

Press

AUSTRIJA NA IVICI KOLAPSA! [Bosnian]


Informer, Nov 18, 2021

Press

Признаки манипуляций [Russian]


Gazeta Pravda, Nov 18, 2021

Press

Komplexitätsforscher zur CoV-Lage


ORF2 | Wien | heute, Nov 17, 2021

Publication

L. Alves, D. Rybski, H. Ribeiro

Commuting network effect on urban wealth scaling

Scientific Reports 11 (2021) 22918

Publication

F. Papst, K. Schodl, O. Saukh

Exploring Co-dependency of IoT Data Quality and Model Robustness in Precision Cattle Farming

in: Proceedings of the 19th ACM Conference on Embedded Networked Sensor Systems (SenSys) '21 (Nov 2021) 433–438

Publication

X. Bao, P. Ji, W. Lin, M. Perc, J. Kurths

The impact of COVID-19 on the worldwide air transportation network

Royal Society Open Science 8 (11) (2021) 210682

Publication

P. Dutta, et al.

Inferring temporal dynamics from cross-sectional data using Langevin dynamics

Royal Society Open Science (8) (2021) 211374

Publication

M. Surucu, Y. Isler, M. Perc, R. Kara

Convolutional neural networks predict the onset of paroxysmal atrial fibrillation: Theory and applications

Chaos 31 (2021) 113119

Publication

A. Kolchinsky, D. Wolpert

Dependence of integrated, instantaneous, and fluctuating entropy production on the initial state in quantum and classical processes

Physical Review E 104 (2021) 054107

Publication

B. Conrady

Epidemiological, mitigation and economic impact of zoonoses [Editorial]

International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 18 (21) (2021) 11704

Publication

T. Ruprechter, M. H. Ribeiro, T. Santos, F. Lemmerich, M. Strohmaier, R. West, D. Helic

Volunteer contributions to Wikipedia increased during COVID-19 mobility restrictions

Scientific Reports 11 (2021) 21505

Publication

J. González-Cabañas, Á. Cuevas, R. Cuevas, J. López-Fernández, D. García

Unique on Facebook: formulation and evidence of (nano)targeting individual users with non-PII data

in: IMC '21: Proceedings of the 21st ACM Internet Measurement Conference, November (2021) 464–479

Publication

T. Marschik, et al.

What are the human resources required to control a foot-and-mouth disease outbreak in Austria?

Frontiers in Veterinary Science 8 (2021)

Publication

C. Matzhold, et al.

A systematic approach to analyse the impact of farm-profiles on bovine health

Scientific Reports 11 (1) (2021) 21152

Publication

A. Peralta, J. Kertész, G. Iniguez

Effect of algorithmic bias and network structure on coexistence, consensus, and polarization of opinions

Physical Review E 104 (2021) 044312