New music styles: how the challenger calls the tune - CSH Vienna

New music styles: how the challenger calls the tune


Feb 6, 2019

[CSH Press Release]

 

What drives fashion changes?

 

A quantitative network analysis of almost eight million musical albums, released between 1956 and 2015, offers an answer to a century-old debate.

 

[Vienna, February 6, 2019] A research team led by scientists at the Complexity Science Hub Vienna (CSH) found that fashion cycles in music are driven by outsider groups. These outsiders challenge the dominant music style by strongly contrasting the preferences of the current elite, for instance, by using different instrumentation or new rhythms. “They use counter-signaling,” explains Stefan Thurner, one of the authors of a new paper in the Journal of the Royal Society Interface. “To put it very bluntly: With a new style, music producers try to slap the old one in the face,” says Thurner.

 

The social dynamics that lead to new fashions and trends have long been, and still are, subject to heated debate and contradictory theories in sociology. The “costly signaling theory,” for example, claims that elites try to establish distinctions by using styles that are too costly to be adopted by non-members of the group. In contrast to this top-down approach, random-pattern theories postulate that elites randomly pick features from non-elite groups and incorporate them to create a new style from the bottom-up.

 

Peter Klimek and Stefan Thurner, both CSH and Medical University of Vienna, and Robert Kreuzbauer, University of Surrey, propose an alternative explanation for the evolution of new styles: elite competition in the form of opposition—scientifically called counter-signaling. Elites are defined in this paper as social groups with disproportionate access to certain resources. In the context of music production, elites are those who dominate the most popular music style(s) at a given time.

 

The scientists tested the three approaches of costly signaling theory, random-pattern theories and counter-dominance signaling, with a large dataset containing almost eight million musical albums, released between 1956 and 2015. The data were derived from Discogs, a crowdsourced online music database. Discogs provides detailed user-generated information on millions of albums, such as artists or instrumentation, and the assignment of each record to one or several of 422 different musical styles.

 

“We first analyzed whether non-elites imitate elements like music arrangements, sounds or production techniques of current elites,” says Peter Klimek. “We found that this happens a lot. After the breakthrough of the American rock band Nirvana, for instance, a whole wave of alternative rock bands adopted elements of Nirvana’s grunge style in the 1990s.”

 

Next the researchers tested the costly-signaling theory: Would the most popular musicians abandon their style once newcomers started to copy them? “We found the contrary,” replies Klimek. “Elites rather like to see others adopt their symbols and styles. It might be a sign of their cultural influence.”

 

Finally, they examined whether new musical styles emerge at random, as random-pattern theories would suggest. They did not, Klimek states. “New styles clearly show counter-signals that provocatively challenge the currently popular styles.” The grungy rock of Nirvana thumbed its nose at highly polished stadium rock of the ’80s with bands like Queen or Guns N’ Roses; punk was a counter-signal to the hugely popular “soft rock” of the ’70s with musicians like Elton John, Simon & Garfunkel or Tina Turner leading the charts, says the complexity scientist. “Once the new style is adopted by a sufficiently large number of followers, its representatives become the new elite and the cycle starts from the beginning.”

 

“We demonstrate with a strictly data-driven, quantitative method that new fashions in music gain their impulse from a strong opposition to current trends,” Stefan Thurner points out. “This should also be tested for in other domains, be they architecture, art, fashion, or even politics and science. In the case of musical styles, the counter-signaling hypothesis best explains how novelty emerges.”

 

Beyond styles, the paper shows “how Big Data analytics can be used to come to a better understanding of the many layers of complex dynamics in human society—here, how elites come to power, persist for a while, and eventually get overthrown,” concludes Thurner.

 

Peter Klimek, Robert Kreuzbauer, Stefan Thurner, Fashion and art cycles are driven by counter-dominance signals of elite competition: Quantitative evidence from music styles, J. R. Soc. Interface 20180731. http://dx.doi.org/10.1098/rsif.2018.0731

 

 


Event

CSH Workshop: “Using Mobile Telephony Data for Societal Insight”


Dec 10, 2019 | 9:30Dec 11, 2019 | 17:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Event

CSH Talk by Stefan Schmid: “Self-adjusting networks”


Dec 06, 2019 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Talk

“Immersive analytics of large dynamic networks via overview and detail navigation”


Johannes Sorger.

Dec 11, 2019 | 14:2515:00

San Diego, California

Press

Unsozialer Feldzug


bauernladen.at, Dec 4, 2019

Event

CSH Talk by Tiago Santos: “Self- and Cross-Excitation in Stack Exchange Question & Answers Communities”


Dec 04, 2019 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Press

Will the US Drag Canada into the ‘Turbulent 2020s’?


The Tyee, Nov 28, 2019

Press

Fleischesser lancierten Twitter-Kampagne gegen Lancet-Forscher


Der Standard, Nov 27, 2019

Press

How pro-meat Twitter scrambled the rollout of the planetary health diet


Quartz, Nov 26, 2019

News

Nov 26, 2019

Planetary Health Diet under attack by pro-meat movement

News

Nov 11, 2019

Stress testing the health care system

News

Oct 22, 2019

What boosts creative work in teams?

News

Oct 6, 2019

Out now: Sustainability colloquium | The Videos

Event

CSH Workshop: “Using Mobile Telephony Data for Societal Insight”


Dec 10, 2019 | 9:30Dec 11, 2019 | 17:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Event

CSH Talk by Stefan Schmid: “Self-adjusting networks”


Dec 06, 2019 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Talk

“Immersive analytics of large dynamic networks via overview and detail navigation”


Johannes Sorger.

Dec 11, 2019 | 14:2515:00

San Diego, California

Press

Unsozialer Feldzug


bauernladen.at, Dec 4, 2019

Event

CSH Talk by Tiago Santos: “Self- and Cross-Excitation in Stack Exchange Question & Answers Communities”


Dec 04, 2019 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Press

Will the US Drag Canada into the ‘Turbulent 2020s’?


The Tyee, Nov 28, 2019

Press

Fleischesser lancierten Twitter-Kampagne gegen Lancet-Forscher


Der Standard, Nov 27, 2019

Press

How pro-meat Twitter scrambled the rollout of the planetary health diet


Quartz, Nov 26, 2019

News

Nov 26, 2019

Planetary Health Diet under attack by pro-meat movement

News

Nov 11, 2019

Stress testing the health care system

News

Oct 22, 2019

What boosts creative work in teams?

News

Oct 6, 2019

Out now: Sustainability colloquium | The Videos

News

Nov 26, 2019

Planetary Health Diet under attack by pro-meat movement

News

Nov 11, 2019

Stress testing the health care system

News

Oct 22, 2019

What boosts creative work in teams?

News

Oct 6, 2019

Out now: Sustainability colloquium | The Videos

News

Sep 30, 2019

Do statins increase osteoporosis risk?

News

Jun 11, 2019

Predicting success in show biz

News

Jun 5, 2019

13 Reasons Why | watching suicide in TV can be contagious

News

May 29, 2019

D4Dairy annual meeting at the Hub

News

Apr 11, 2019

Shocking Economics!

News

Apr 3, 2019

In need of ‘complexity economics’

News

Mar 20, 2019

Complex societies gave birth to big gods

News

Feb 6, 2019

New music styles: how the challenger calls the tune

Event

CSH Workshop: “Using Mobile Telephony Data for Societal Insight”


Dec 10, 2019 | 9:30Dec 11, 2019 | 17:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Event

CSH Talk by Stefan Schmid: “Self-adjusting networks”


Dec 06, 2019 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Talk

“Immersive analytics of large dynamic networks via overview and detail navigation”


Johannes Sorger.

Dec 11, 2019 | 14:2515:00

San Diego, California

Event

CSH Talk by Tiago Santos: “Self- and Cross-Excitation in Stack Exchange Question & Answers Communities”


Dec 04, 2019 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Event

CSH Talk by R. Maria del Rio Chanona: “Occupational mobility and Automation: A data-driven network model”


Dec 05, 2019 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Talk

“Predicting collapse of adaptive networked systems without knowing the network”


Jan Korbel.

Dec 12, 2019 | 11:1512:45

Calouste Gulbenkian Foundation

Event

CSH Talk by Andrew Ringsmuth: “Towards resilience from local to global—the challenge of scale in social-ecological system dynamics”


Nov 27, 2019 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Event

CSH Talk by Balázs Lengyel: “Inequality is rising where social network segregation interacts with urban topology”


Nov 28, 2019 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Event

CSH Talk by Christian Diem: “Optimal financial networks and measuring systemic risk in multilayer networks”


Nov 29, 2019 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Talk

“Die Bedeutung von Big Data in der Präzisionsmedizin”


Stefan Thurner.

Nov 23, 2019 | 10:2511:00

MQ Vienna

Visitor

Andrea Gadotti, Imperial College London


Dec 10, 2019Dec 11, 2019

Visitor

Heiko Lehmann, T-Labs


Dec 10, 2019Dec 11, 2019

Press

Unsozialer Feldzug


bauernladen.at, Dec 4, 2019

Press

Will the US Drag Canada into the ‘Turbulent 2020s’?


The Tyee, Nov 28, 2019

Press

Fleischesser lancierten Twitter-Kampagne gegen Lancet-Forscher


Der Standard, Nov 27, 2019

Press

How pro-meat Twitter scrambled the rollout of the planetary health diet


Quartz, Nov 26, 2019

Press

Las redes sociales ‘boicotearon’ la «dieta de salud planetaria» [Spanish]


ABC.es, Nov 26, 2019

Press

Wie Twitter-Kampagne Ernährungs-Empfehlungen gezielt unterminierte


APA Science, Nov 26, 2019

Press

Fleischfans gegen „Planetary Diet“


ORF Science, Nov 26, 2019

Press

Globaler Provinzialismus in der Ökonomie


FAZ, Nov 23, 2019

Press

La modélisation de l’histoire prédit un cycle de crises dès 2020


SLATE France / korii, Nov 18, 2019

Press

History as a giant data set: how analysing the past could help save the future


The Guardian, Nov 12, 2019

Press

Stresstest für das Gesundheitssystem [7 Tage abrufbar]


Ö1 Journale, Nov 12, 2019

Press

Nicht nur Frage der Ärztedichte


ORF Science, Nov 12, 2019