New theory explains political polarization - CSH

New theory explains political polarization


Jun 29, 2020

Scientists at the CSH expand an old theory of balance to explain the emergence of hyperpolarization

 

A new model of opinion formation shows how the extent to which people like or dislike each other affects their political views and vice versa. The resulting division of societies can even become a matter of life and death, as the current crises show.

 

The ever-deepening rift between the political left- and right-wing has long been puzzling theorists in political science and opinion dynamics. An international team led by researchers of the Complexity Science Hub Vienna (CSH) now offers an explanation: Their newly developed “Weighted Balance Theory” (WBT) model sees social emotions as a driving force of political opinion dynamics. The theory is published in the Journal of Artificial Societies and Social Simulation (JASSS).

 

A certain degree of polarization of political opinions is considered normal–and even beneficial–to the health of democracy. In the last few decades, however, conservative and liberal views have been drifting farther apart than ever, and at the same time have become more consistent. When too much polarization hampers a nation’s ability to combat threats such as the coronavirus pandemic, it can even be deadly.

 

How do extreme positions evolve?

 

“We feel high balance when dealing with someone we like and with whom we agree in all political issues,” explains first author Simon Schweighofer, who was a PostDoc at the Hub when the paper was written. “We also feel high balance towards those we hate and with whom we disagree,” adds the expert in quantitative social science. The human tendency to maintain emotional balance was first described 1946 by Fritz Heider’s “cognitive balance theory.”

 

But what happens when opinions and interpersonal attitudes are in conflict with each other, i.e., when individuals disagree with others they like, or agree with others they dislike? “People will try to overcome this imbalance by adapting their opinions, in order to increase balance with their emotions,” says Simon.

 

A vicious circle of increasingly intense emotions and opinions gradually replaces moderate positions until most issues are seen in the same—often extremely polarized—way as one’s political allies, the scientists found.

 

“It ultimately ends in total polarization,” illustrates co-author David Garcia (CSH, MedUni Vienna). Not only do people categorically favor or oppose single issues like abortion, same-sex marriage and nuclear energy. “If they are pro-choice, they are at the same time highly likely to be for gay marriage, against the use of nuclear energy, for the legalization of marijuana, and so on.” The possible variety of combinations of different opinions is reduced to black and white—the traditional left-right split.

 

A mathematical model of hyperpolarization

 

The researchers developed a so-called agent-based model to simulate this process. Their mathematical model was able to reproduce the same dynamics that can be observed in real-life political processes (see videos below).

 

“We call the combination of extremeness and correlation between policy issues hyperpolarization,“ says Simon. “Hyperpolarization has so far been overlooked in social theories on opinion formation. Our Weighted Balance Model—which is a truly interdisciplinary effort that integrates research strains from psychology, political science and opinion dynamics into an overarching theoretical framework—offers a new perspective on the emergence of political conflict,” he concludes.

 

The study, entitled A Weighted Balance Model of Opinion Hyperpolarization”, will appear in print on 30 June 2020 in the Journal of Artificial Societies and Social Simulation.

 

 

 

Video 1:

Emergence of hyperpolarization

 

 

 

The simulation demonstrates the emergence of hyperpolarization, showing the link between social emotions and opinion divergence.

 

The three dimensions correspond to three political issues (e.g., marihuana legalization, gay marriage, or income taxation). The space spanned by these dimensions is the “opinion space.” Each blue dot represents an individual. From random positions, individuals rapidly converge in the middle of the opinion space (where all three issues are irrelevant). At the same time, they align themselves along a diagonal, corresponding to the political spectrum, i.e. from far left to center to far right. In the next step, they split into two groups, corresponding to political parties. Members of the same party now have identical opinions on all three issues, and opposing opinions to the other party. This conflict creates positive feelings towards one’s party colleagues and animosity towards the other party, driving the individuals ever further apart, until they are in opposite corners of the opinion space.

 

 

Video 2:

Opinion change and weighted balance

 

 

 

This simulation shows how individuals react to another individual according to his/her changing opinions.

 

As individual 1 [red arrow] moves in a circle through the opinion space, others [the black arrows] with already similar opinions (i.e. whose opinion vector is less than 90 degrees away from individual 1), and thus a positive relation towards the individual, move closer. Others who dislike the individual due to differing opinions move away. Repeated interaction leads to individuals either agreeing with on all issues, or adopting opposing views. The background color shows how much cognitive balance they perceive.

 

 

 

 

 


Press

DELTA-VARIANTE: KOMMT VIERTE WELLE?


Puls 4 | Cafe Puls, Jun 24, 2021

Press

Corona: Von Wut über Angst zur Trauer


Ö1 | Digital Leben, Jun 22, 2021

News

Jun 22, 2021

Digital Humanism: CSH successful with three projects

Press

Delta-Variante erschwert das Erreichen einer Herdenimmunität


Oberösterreichisches Volksblatt, Jun 22, 2021

Press

Warnungen vor zu frühem Ende der Maskenpflicht im Handel und in Öffis


OÖ Nachrichten, Jun 22, 2021

News

Jun 17, 2021

TU Wien–CSH Vienna COVID-19 project | Final Report

Publication

F.F. Roch, B. Conrady

Overview of mitigation programmes for non-EU regulated cattle diseases in Austria

Frontiers in Veterinary Science 8 (2021) 689244

Publication

V. Richter, et al.

Animal-related factors predicting fatal cases of blackleg and gas gangrene in cattle

Veterinary Record (2021)

News

Jun 4, 2021

Blog | Anna Di Natale: “Affective meaning in language”

Publication

N. Savela, A. Oksanen, M. Pellert, D. Garcia

Emotional reactions to robot colleagues in a role-playing experiment

International Journal of Information Management 60 (2021) 102361

News

May 17, 2021

CSH leads “Initiative for a National Medical Data Agency”

Publication

A. Di Natale, M. Pellert, D. Garcia

Colexification networks encode affective meaning

Affective Science (2021)

Press

DELTA-VARIANTE: KOMMT VIERTE WELLE?


Puls 4 | Cafe Puls, Jun 24, 2021

Press

Corona: Von Wut über Angst zur Trauer


Ö1 | Digital Leben, Jun 22, 2021

News

Jun 22, 2021

Digital Humanism: CSH successful with three projects

Press

Delta-Variante erschwert das Erreichen einer Herdenimmunität


Oberösterreichisches Volksblatt, Jun 22, 2021

Press

Warnungen vor zu frühem Ende der Maskenpflicht im Handel und in Öffis


OÖ Nachrichten, Jun 22, 2021

News

Jun 17, 2021

TU Wien–CSH Vienna COVID-19 project | Final Report

Publication

F.F. Roch, B. Conrady

Overview of mitigation programmes for non-EU regulated cattle diseases in Austria

Frontiers in Veterinary Science 8 (2021) 689244

Publication

V. Richter, et al.

Animal-related factors predicting fatal cases of blackleg and gas gangrene in cattle

Veterinary Record (2021)

News

Jun 4, 2021

Blog | Anna Di Natale: “Affective meaning in language”

Publication

N. Savela, A. Oksanen, M. Pellert, D. Garcia

Emotional reactions to robot colleagues in a role-playing experiment

International Journal of Information Management 60 (2021) 102361

News

May 17, 2021

CSH leads “Initiative for a National Medical Data Agency”

Publication

A. Di Natale, M. Pellert, D. Garcia

Colexification networks encode affective meaning

Affective Science (2021)

News

Jun 22, 2021

Digital Humanism: CSH successful with three projects

News

Jun 17, 2021

TU Wien–CSH Vienna COVID-19 project | Final Report

News

Jun 4, 2021

Blog | Anna Di Natale: “Affective meaning in language”

News

May 17, 2021

CSH leads “Initiative for a National Medical Data Agency”

News

May 12, 2021

Blog | Andrew Ringsmuth: “How to deal with urgent global challenges”

News

Apr 19, 2021

The (scaling) laws of the jungle

News

Apr 16, 2021

Paul Watzlawick Ring of Honor for Stefan and Peter

News

Apr 1, 2021

CSH Winter Lecture Series: from the Alps to Zoom

News

Mar 17, 2021

The City Formula or: It’s all about geometry!

News

Mar 12, 2021

Videos out!!! Watch the Covid-19 Measures Tracker Conference

News

Mar 5, 2021

Hostile attitudes to migrants harden by short-term exposure

News

Feb 18, 2021

(Re)Shaping cities to combat inequality

Press

DELTA-VARIANTE: KOMMT VIERTE WELLE?


Puls 4 | Cafe Puls, Jun 24, 2021

Press

Corona: Von Wut über Angst zur Trauer


Ö1 | Digital Leben, Jun 22, 2021

Press

Delta-Variante erschwert das Erreichen einer Herdenimmunität


Oberösterreichisches Volksblatt, Jun 22, 2021

Press

Warnungen vor zu frühem Ende der Maskenpflicht im Handel und in Öffis


OÖ Nachrichten, Jun 22, 2021

Press

„EM-Siegeszug realistischer als neuer Lockdown“


Kronen Zeitung, Jun 21, 2021

Press

Komplexitätsforscher Klimek: Lockert die Regierung zu viel und zu früh?


ORF 2 | ZIB 2, Jun 21, 2021

Press

Forscher: “Vierte Welle wird kommen”


oe24, Jun 21, 2021

Press

Klimek: Eine vierte Welle wird kommen


Puls 24 | News Chronik, Jun 21, 2021

Press

Modellierer Klimek: Wir müssen uns jetzt auf die Delta-Variante vorbereiten


Ö1 | Mittagsjournal, Jun 21, 2021

Press

PCR-Tests sollen ausgeweitet werden


ORF Online, Jun 21, 2021

Press

Lockdown im Herbst? Forscher hält Sieg Österreichs gegen Italien für “wahrscheinlicher”


Kurier, Jun 21, 2021

Press

Die Rückkehr der Wiener Society [Print]


Kleine Zeitung, Jun 19, 2021

Publication

F.F. Roch, B. Conrady

Overview of mitigation programmes for non-EU regulated cattle diseases in Austria

Frontiers in Veterinary Science 8 (2021) 689244

Publication

V. Richter, et al.

Animal-related factors predicting fatal cases of blackleg and gas gangrene in cattle

Veterinary Record (2021)

Publication

N. Savela, A. Oksanen, M. Pellert, D. Garcia

Emotional reactions to robot colleagues in a role-playing experiment

International Journal of Information Management 60 (2021) 102361

Publication

A. Di Natale, M. Pellert, D. Garcia

Colexification networks encode affective meaning

Affective Science (2021)

Publication

V.M. Ilić, J. Korbel, S. Gupta, A.M. Scarfone

An overview of generalized entropic forms

Europhysics Letters 133 (5) (2021) 50005

Publication

M. Leutner, et al.

Risk of Typical Diabetes-Associated Complications in Different Clusters of Diabetic Patients: Analysis of Nine Risk Factors

Journal of Personalized Medicine 11 (5) (2021) 328

Publication

J. Lasser, et al.

Power abuse and anonymous accusations in academia – Perspectives …

Beiträge zur Hochschulforschung, 43. Jahrgang (1–2) (2021) 48–61

Publication

E. Wagner, et al.

Bacteria of eleven different species isolated from biofilms in a meat processing environment have diverse biofilm forming abilities

International Journal of Food Microbiology 349 (2021) 109232

Publication

J. Lasser, M. Ernst, L. Goehring

Stability and dynamics of convection in dry salt lakes

Journal of Fluid Mechanics 917 (2021) A14

Publication

D. Andersson, S. Bratsberg, A. K. Ringsmuth, A. S. de Wijn

Dynamics of collective action to conserve a large common-pool resource

Scientific Reports 11 (2021) 9208

Publication

B. Tadic, R. Melnik

Microscopic dynamics modeling unravels the role of asymptomatic virus carriers in SARS-CoV-2 epidemics at the interplay between biological and social factors

Computers in Biology and Medicine 133 (2021) 104422

Publication

G. Papp, I. Kondor, F. Caccioli

Optimizing Expected Shortfall under an ℓ1 Constraint—An Analytic Approach

Entropy 23 (5) (2021) 523