Testing theories on What drove the Holocene transformation


Jun 24, 2022

The Seshat project helps to single out those theories on socio-political evolution that are backed by data

 

An international research team led by CSH’s Peter Turchin uses a new dynamical model and the exceptional historical data collection “Seshat” to examine major explanations for the evolution of cultural complexity – and finds little support for many, even very influential, theories.

 

During the past 10,000 years – the so called Holocene – human societies became larger and ever more complex. What were the main drivers of the increasing complexity? The well experienced “Seshat” team around Peter Turchin once again used its huge Seshat: Global History Databank to put various theories that were developed to explain that process to the test.

 

According to the team’s newest findings, published today in the journal Science Advances, the best explanation for the evolution of socio-cultural complexity is a combination of increasing agricultural productivity and the invention, or adoption, of military technologies (most notably, the invention of iron weapons and cavalry in the first millennium BCE).

Read what Science News reported on this study (June 28, 2022):

Does warfare make societies more complex? Controversial study says yes

Archaeological analysis suggests an arms race in ironworking and cavalry spurred bureaucracy and bigger populations.

Many theories to be tested

 

“Countless explanations have been offered over the years to explain the incredible ‘Holocene transformation’”, Peter points out. Some theorists, like Jared Diamond, say that the transition to agriculture was both the necessary and sufficient condition for the rise of complex societies. Other theories focus on conflict theories, class struggle, the threat from external warfare or functionalist explanations, e.g., that complex social organization evolved to solve certain problems faced by societies.

 

“All these theories could cite historical examples seemingly supporting their putative mechanisms; but none have ever proven decisively more convincing than the others,” says Peter, who leads a team investigating Social Complexity and Collapse at the Hub.

 

Along with fellow members of the Seshat project, he applied the tried-and-true scientific method: determine what each body of theory proposes as the key factors driving the rise of complexity and see which one best explains the available empirical evidence.

 

The results reveal that many long-standing and influential theories receive little support from data.

 

Plough and sword drive human history

 

The best explanation for the observed patterns offers the framework of cultural evolution. “Essentially, the conflict between groups over territory and resources put a tremendous selective pressure on societies,” Peter explains. It favored societies that were ever larger, more populous, could store more information and communicate effectively at greater distances and were capable of mobilizing larger numbers of people for common projects like defense and maintaining public infrastructure. “While previous theories contained some of these elements, for the first time a single, coherent framework has been provided and demonstrated with the historical record,” he says.

 

The scholars also identified several major “transformations” during the Holocene: Following the invention of key technologies like bronze and later iron smelting or cavalry warfare and associated tactics, the scale of the largest societies rose dramatically before levelling off to a relatively stable size. New innovations and cultural adaptations continued to build until another breakthrough was achieved, propelling societies to new heights before stabilizing again, while the whole process began anew.

 

Big Data reveal decisive patterns

 

“This paper is the culmination of more than a decade of intensive collaboration,” says Harvey Whitehouse, corresponding author on the paper and one of the founding directors of Seshat. “Our study utilized more than a hundred variables – meticulously coded – relating to 373 societies that flourished between 9600 BCE and 1900 CE. With the help of such ’big’ data we are able to place theories of world history head-to-head and see which ones win.”

 

The scientists view this study as a breakthrough in the understanding of how human societies have evolved since the very first farmers settled down thousands of years ago. In the future, the team will adopt similar methods to test the diverse group of ideas that have been proposed in other areas of research, such as the causes of societal collapse or the role of religious ideology in cultural evolution.

 

The ultimate goal, as Peter puts it, is to “put those influential ideas that do not bear out against the empirical record to bed, once and for all”.

 

 

The study “Disentangling the evolutionary drivers of social complexity in human history: A comprehensive test of hypotheses” by Peter Turchin, Harvey Whitehouse, Sergey Gavrilets, Daniel Hoyer, Pieter François, James S Bennett, Kevin Feeney, Peter Peregrine, Gary Feinman, Andrey Korotayev, Nikolay Kradin, Jill Levine, Jenny Reddish, Enrico Cioni, Romain Wacziarg, Gavin Mendelson-Gleason, Majid Benam is published in Science Advances.

 

English Press Release


Research News

Dec 6, 2022

Complexity Science meets Digital Humanism

Press

COVID-19 in Austria: Why scientists learned to speak [feat.Peter Klimek]


Nature Portfolio, Dec 8, 2022

People

Nov 30, 2022

Bridging the gap between academia and industry

Publication

W. Schueller, J. Wachs, V. D. P. Servedio, S. Thurner, V. Loreto

Evolving collaboration, dependencies, and use in the Rust Open Source Software ecosystem

Scientific Data 9 (2022) 703

Publication

H. Kong, S. Martin-Gutierrez, F. Karimi

Influence of the first-mover advantage on the gender disparities in physics citations

Communications Physics 5 (243) (2022)

Event

CSH Talk by Zlata Tabachová: "Supply chain shock propagation and financial systemic risk"


Dec 02, 2022 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Event

CSH Talk by visiting scientist Meike Zehlike: "Fairness Criteria in Machine Learning and Law"


Dec 16, 2022 | 14:0014:30

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Event

CSH Talk by Elma Dervic: "Unravelling cradle-to-grave disease trajectories from multilayer comorbidity networks"


Dec 16, 2022 | 14:3015:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Press

Marginalization Effects in Face-to-face Social Networks [feat.Fariba Karimi]


SIAM, Dec 7, 2022

Press

MAMMOth: KI-Tendenz zur Diskriminierung durchbrechen [feat.Fariba Karimi]


Brutkasten, Nov 22, 2022

Spotlight

Dec 2, 2022

Avoiding supply chain bottlenecks with Big Data

Publication

N. Pontika, T. Klebel, A. Correia, H. Metzler, P. Knoth, T. Ross-Hellauer

Indicators of research quality, quantity, openness and responsibility in institutional review, promotion and tenure policies across seven countries

Quantitative Science Studies 1-49

Research News

Dec 6, 2022

Complexity Science meets Digital Humanism

Press

COVID-19 in Austria: Why scientists learned to speak [feat.Peter Klimek]


Nature Portfolio, Dec 8, 2022

People

Nov 30, 2022

Bridging the gap between academia and industry

Publication

W. Schueller, J. Wachs, V. D. P. Servedio, S. Thurner, V. Loreto

Evolving collaboration, dependencies, and use in the Rust Open Source Software ecosystem

Scientific Data 9 (2022) 703

Publication

H. Kong, S. Martin-Gutierrez, F. Karimi

Influence of the first-mover advantage on the gender disparities in physics citations

Communications Physics 5 (243) (2022)

Event

CSH Talk by Zlata Tabachová: "Supply chain shock propagation and financial systemic risk"


Dec 02, 2022 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Event

CSH Talk by visiting scientist Meike Zehlike: "Fairness Criteria in Machine Learning and Law"


Dec 16, 2022 | 14:0014:30

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Event

CSH Talk by Elma Dervic: "Unravelling cradle-to-grave disease trajectories from multilayer comorbidity networks"


Dec 16, 2022 | 14:3015:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Press

Marginalization Effects in Face-to-face Social Networks [feat.Fariba Karimi]


SIAM, Dec 7, 2022

Press

MAMMOth: KI-Tendenz zur Diskriminierung durchbrechen [feat.Fariba Karimi]


Brutkasten, Nov 22, 2022

Spotlight

Dec 2, 2022

Avoiding supply chain bottlenecks with Big Data

Publication

N. Pontika, T. Klebel, A. Correia, H. Metzler, P. Knoth, T. Ross-Hellauer

Indicators of research quality, quantity, openness and responsibility in institutional review, promotion and tenure policies across seven countries

Quantitative Science Studies 1-49

People

Nov 30, 2022

Bridging the gap between academia and industry

Research News

Dec 6, 2022

Complexity Science meets Digital Humanism

Spotlight

Dec 2, 2022

Avoiding supply chain bottlenecks with Big Data

Research News

Nov 28, 2022

New evidence for possible domino effects in cryptoassets

Spotlight

Nov 28, 2022

BUSTS AFTER BOOMS, BUT WHY?

Research News

Nov 17, 2022

New EU project to reduce discrimination through AI

Research News

Oct 13, 2022

Yes we can -- STEM is also for women

Research News

Oct 13, 2022

Predicting the economic downturn during the pandemic

Press

COVID-19 in Austria: Why scientists learned to speak [feat.Peter Klimek]


Nature Portfolio, Dec 8, 2022

Press

Marginalization Effects in Face-to-face Social Networks [feat.Fariba Karimi]


SIAM, Dec 7, 2022

Press

MAMMOth: KI-Tendenz zur Diskriminierung durchbrechen [feat.Fariba Karimi]


Brutkasten, Nov 22, 2022

Press

Was crime as bad as it was portrayed [feat.Rafael Prieto-Curiel]


abcNEWS, Nov 18, 2022

Press

A charada do desequilibrio de genero na ciencia [Portuguese] [feat.Fariba Karimi]


Pesquisa Fapesp, Nov 17, 2022

Press

COVID : Les animaux peuvent-ils attraper le virus? [French] [feat.Amélie Desvars-Larrive]


News24, Nov 17, 2022

Press

Departure of Tech Workers Weighs on Russian Economy [feat.Johannes Wachs]


The Wall Street Journal, Nov 14, 2022

Press

Männer profitieren stärker vom Pionier-Vorteil als Frauen [feat.Fariba Karimi]


Spektrum Online, Oct 26, 2022

Press

Can your phone tell if a bridge is in good shape?


Scienmag, Nov 3, 2022

Press

Which Animals Catch COVID? This Database Has Dozens of Species and Counting [feat.Amélie Desvars-Larrive]


Scientific American, Oct 19, 2022

Publication

W. Schueller, J. Wachs, V. D. P. Servedio, S. Thurner, V. Loreto

Evolving collaboration, dependencies, and use in the Rust Open Source Software ecosystem

Scientific Data 9 (2022) 703

Publication

N. Pontika, T. Klebel, A. Correia, H. Metzler, P. Knoth, T. Ross-Hellauer

Indicators of research quality, quantity, openness and responsibility in institutional review, promotion and tenure policies across seven countries

Quantitative Science Studies 1-49

Publication

H. Kong, S. Martin-Gutierrez, F. Karimi

Influence of the first-mover advantage on the gender disparities in physics citations

Communications Physics 5 (243) (2022)

Publication

A. Pichler, M. Pangallo, M. del Rio-Chanona, F. Lafond, D. Farmer

Forecasting the propagation of pandemic shocks with a dynamic input-output model

Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control (2022) 104527

Publication

J. Lasser, S. Taofeek Aroyehun, et al.

Social media sharing of low quality news sources by political elites

PNAS Nexus (2022) pgac186

Publication

R. Prieto Curiel, A. Schumann, I. Heo, P. Heinrigs

Detecting cities with high intermediacy in the African urban network

Computers, Environment and Urban Systems 98 (2022) 101869

Publication

T. Reisch, G. Heiler, C. Diem, P. Klimek, S. Thurner

Monitoring supply networks from mobile phone data for estimating the systemic risk of an economy

Scientific Reports 12 (13347) (2022)

Publication

G. De Marzo, F. Pandolfelli, V.D.P. Servedio

Modeling innovation in the cryptocurrency ecosystem

Scientific Reports 12 (12942) (2022)

Publication

A. Nerpel, et al.

SARS-ANI: a global open access dataset of reported SARS-CoV-2 events in animals

Scientific Data 9 (438) (2022)

Publication

M. Kaleta, J. Lasser, E. Dervic, et al.

Stress-testing the resilience of the Austrian healthcare system using agent-based simulation

Nature Communications 13 (4259) (2022)

Publication

F. Amman, et al.

Viral variant-resolved wastewater surveillance of SARS-CoV-2 at national scale

Nature Biotechnology (2022)

Publication

J. V. Camp, A. Desvars-Larrive, N. Nowotny, C. Walzer

Monitoring urban zoonotic virus activity: Are city rats a promising surveillance tool for emerging viruses?

Viruses 14 (7) (2022) 1516

Event

CSH Talk by Zlata Tabachová: "Supply chain shock propagation and financial systemic risk"


Dec 02, 2022 | 15:0016:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Event

CSH Workshop: "Innovation and obsolescence in the space of the possible"


Dec 12, 2022Dec 14, 2022

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Event

CSH Talk by visiting scientist Meike Zehlike: "Fairness Criteria in Machine Learning and Law"


Dec 16, 2022 | 14:0014:30

Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Event

CSH Talk by Elma Dervic: "Unravelling cradle-to-grave disease trajectories from multilayer comorbidity networks"


Dec 16, 2022 | 14:3015:00

Complexity Science Hub Vienna